Re:The Dying Art of Disagreement
by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @08:31PM
(#15343894)
> It is impossible for two honest, truth-seeking people to disagree about a fact in perpetuity
Since people are mortal, the “honest” and “truth-seeking” qualifiers are superfluous.
It is, on the other hand, for honest and truth-seeking people to disagree on a matter of fact for as long as either lives, which is as close to “in perpetuity” as can matter for them.
More relevantly, perhaps, it is quite possible for an honest and truth-seeking individual to decide that the cost in time and other resources to resolve a disagreement with another such person is not justified, and for such a decision to be reciprocal, hence an agreement to disagree on a matter D fact.
> Many political disagreements are, of course, not factual, but rather based on values.
Almost all political disagreements are, at root, disagreements about values or definitions, not facts, and those few that are about facts are often rooted in different fundamental beliefs about epistemology, rather than being resolvable in a shared epistemic framework.
Since people are mortal, the “honest” and “truth-seeking” qualifiers are superfluous.
It is, on the other hand, for honest and truth-seeking people to disagree on a matter of fact for as long as either lives, which is as close to “in perpetuity” as can matter for them.
More relevantly, perhaps, it is quite possible for an honest and truth-seeking individual to decide that the cost in time and other resources to resolve a disagreement with another such person is not justified, and for such a decision to be reciprocal, hence an agreement to disagree on a matter D fact.
> Many political disagreements are, of course, not factual, but rather based on values.
Almost all political disagreements are, at root, disagreements about values or definitions, not facts, and those few that are about facts are often rooted in different fundamental beliefs about epistemology, rather than being resolvable in a shared epistemic framework.