News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by kemerover on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:21AM (#15330176)
People should report crimes to police, they shouldn't report them to school or company. Everyone who tells the opposite enables sexual assault. Uber is not at fault in this situation and it doesn't enable anything.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by pjc50 on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:23AM (#15330197)
This is not what the Metropolitan Police think. https://cdn.londonreconnections.com/2013/12042017-NB-to-Hele...
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by kemerover on Monday September 25, 2017 @12:38PM (#15331858)
If I understood the letter correctly, what Uber did was not illegal. And if I understand how police works in most countries, if you report a crime to police they are obliged to investigate it

So my point stands. If you think that people shouldn't report crimes, you enable crimes. "‘strongly under the impression’ that they would." is a laughable excuse. What did Uber do that would provide a strong impression, yet wasn't enough to be accused of being misleading in court?

If what Uber did is illegal in UK, they should face punishment. But as far as I can tell, they did nothing illegal in this situation.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by _jal on Monday September 25, 2017 @01:23PM (#15332254)
I see lots of folks trying out an argument along the lines of, "if Uber managers aren't being marched in front of magistrates, then everything's peachy and Leave Uber Alloooone!" I can't wait for the ads "Uber - not officially a criminal enterprise yet!"

Unfortunately, this argument ignores the fact that requirements for unusual privileges - like running massive fleets of vehicles on public streets - are a bit higher than the requirements for staying out of jail.

Reporting sexual assault is not exactly difficult. Whether it is a cynical PR issue, some weird philosophical thing, or simply bizarre institutional/emotional damage around sexual assault[1], Uber has a problem that they are apparently incapable of handling, even with years, warnings and a near complete change of management.

It really is freakish.

[1] Given so many different incidents handled over multiple years in multiple countries, that their competitors don't seem to have the same problem with, I'm starting to wonder, frankly.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by namelost on Monday September 25, 2017 @01:33PM (#15332334)
Nobody is suggesting that Uber did anything illegal, their licence to operate is being revoked.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by kemerover on Monday September 25, 2017 @05:31PM (#15334358)
And I didn't suggest that it shouldn't be revoked.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by Retra on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:27AM (#15330232)
Businesses should also report crimes to the police. A business who does the opposite enables sexual assault. Uber is at fault in this situation and directly enables sexual assault.

The only difference between what I'm saying and what you're saying is that I imply Uber is run by people and you imply they are a force of nature (or something.)

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by kemerover on Monday September 25, 2017 @12:54PM (#15332022)
If you've been a victim of a crime, you should report it. If you've witnessed a crime, you should report it too. Otherwise you enable criminals. If you were told that there were a crime by a random person, you don't have to report it. I think it is as simple as that. I don't think or imply that Uber is a force of nature, I don't know where you got this idea from.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by wukerplank on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:30AM (#15330264)
> Uber is not at fault in this situation

Keeping a sexual predator as a driver is the right choice?

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by Spivak on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:57AM (#15330488)
Oh come on there's way more nuance to this issue than you're letting on. Taking away a person's livelihood can be just as bad as a jail sentence and you're acting like companies should act as judge and executioner in the court of public opinion. What's the point of even having a justice system when we can dispatch a lifetime of suffering by blacklisting suspected criminals from employment?

This whole things seems just like "But her emails!" where people are latching onto anything they can to justify their dislike for something they already hate.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by GrantSolar on Monday September 25, 2017 @10:50AM (#15330909)
Is there really that much more nuance? Uber received a complaint of sexual assault by a driver. The victim was under the impression that Uber would contact the police. Uber did not contact the police and continued to employ the driver. Uber then received a second complaint of sexual assault by the same driver. The second victim was "strongly under the impression" that the police would be contacted. The police were not contacted.

In this situation, Uber are complicit in the second sexual assault to at least some degree. (Perhaps they carried out a thorough investigation which presented nothing. Perhaps they did not carry out an investigation again). They are complicit in any further sexual assaults this driver carries out.

With regards to "Taking away a person's livelihood", that's precisely what a police investigation and CRB/DBS checks are for. The driver simply should not be allowed in such a position if they have a history of sexual assault. No-one is asking for the company to "act as judge and executioner" (in fact, in this case the company is doing exactly that except ruling not-guilty), merely to alert the appropriate authorities so that a legitimate investigation can be carried out according to the established judicial system.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by kemerover on Monday September 25, 2017 @12:45PM (#15331924)
If Uber is complicit, where are the charges? Where are the fines? Where are managers getting jailed for concealment of a crime? Is there even a prosecution?
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by pwinnski on Monday September 25, 2017 @01:20PM (#15332234)
The most direct effect of Uber being complicit is that their license is not being renewed.

And yes, as the article states, there are prosecutions in both cases.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by watwut on Monday September 25, 2017 @03:48PM (#15333472)
Uber is not having license, which is a big punishment I would say, is fine on top also needed? Concealment of a crime and failure to report one are two different things with two different punishments. And while I believe companies crimes should be personalized to managers who lead employees to commit them, where such thing can be proven, jail time for this one would be probably too much of a punishment.

We dont need to jail for everything, really. It is expensive and ineffective overall.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by kemerover on Monday September 25, 2017 @12:41PM (#15331899)
It is the job of the justice system to understand whether he is guilty or not. I think that if a company fires a person for a claim of sexual assault that wasn't proved, this person is justified to sue the fuck out of the company for false pretense.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by Idontknowmyuser on Monday September 25, 2017 @01:41PM (#15332405)
Innocent until proven guilty.Uber respected due process expecting that if the allegation are true the police would have arrested the man. Uber is not a court, it does not and in my opinion should not have the right to play judge.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by totony on Monday September 25, 2017 @02:38PM (#15332852)
Isn't he an alleged* sexual predator?