News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s time to kill the web app by hutzlibu on Saturday September 23, 2017 @07:47PM (#15322409)
I rather think, It's time, to completley ignore sensationalistic rant's like this one.

First of, killing a technology does not solve anything. It just means less options. So do propose your better solution (and build it) - then we can talk about killing the current thing.

But the way it is today, the web works.

Definitely not flawless and in large parts really ugly (just browsing with open dev-tools is horrifying, when you see all the errors and warnings thrown at you) - but it is big and reduntant enough, that you can mostly choose only the nice parts.

XMLHttpRequest is ugly? (I allways thought so) Well, there are WebSockets now.

Javascript lacks typesupport etc? - Use Typescript

The whole DOM and *script languages in general are ugly? Skip it all and use only WebGL and Wasm.

And your app will still run allmost everywhere.

That's the power of the web - that's why it became so important. It just works.

And it is very easy to start doing it ... so many people did this, who do not have a CS background. And obviously they made horrible things from an academic point of view. But things still kind of worked for them.

And security ... well, so far I have not yet heard of a save language/OS/Plattform where people can work productivly without years of studying the theoretic backgrounds.

So in general yes, I am very open for better designed alternatives. In fact I am looking for one since I started web-developement, but not so much for angry hyperbolic rants like this one. They are not helpful.

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by kowdermeister on Saturday September 23, 2017 @08:14PM (#15322511)
What's odd is that this article is so well written that it really clicks with bitter developers who are just confused in the vast sea of alternative technologies with the web. At least that's my guess why there's so many upvotes here.

I feel that anyone who rants like this comes from a low level micromanagement world where they have extreme control over everything any they can't have it with web technologies. Fine, but why shit on other developers carpet?

I think the web platform is one of the best innovation the software industry has experienced since the 80's. Can it be better? Of course, yes, definitely and it's getting better.

I have to agree that posting bitter, "everything is wrong" type of articles is really not constructive.

And for god's sake, learn to use your effin' tools.

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by DINKDINK on Sunday September 24, 2017 @03:42AM (#15323763)
>What's odd is that this article is so well written that it really clicks with bitter developers who are just confused in the vast sea of alternative technologies

Hearn has a penchant for penning very well written articles but complaining about systemic issues rather than directly solving them.

He was the kernel of the block size split that occurred in bitcoin starting in 2015 whose vitriolic fruit still bears today. Rather than face up to the fact that his fix proposals were either technically and or politically dead on arrival, he claimed a vast conspiracy.

There are some valid claims in this post but again it’s too heavy on complaining and light on the solutions.

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by mike_hearn on Sunday September 24, 2017 @09:48AM (#15324676)
I think that's a bit unfair.

Firstly, I did try and solve the block size problem. Myself and Gavin did Bitcoin XT. It resulted in large DDoS attacks that took out entire regional areas because they contained a single XT node, any mention of XT being banned from the Bitcoin forums, large companies like Coinbase being banned too for simply experimenting with it, and so on. Miners also refused to run it because they were told that this would be democracy, and democracy was dangerous (they were almost all in China, so no surprises there). There was a large, organised and extremely hostile effort to ensure that the solutions we proposed could not be adopted even by those who wanted to. I did a lot more than just write articles.

As for this article, it says there's a second part coming where I propose concrete solutions.

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by hutzlibu on Sunday September 24, 2017 @11:24AM (#15325025)
"As for this article, it says there's a second part coming where I propose concrete solutions"

looking forward for it ...

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by taternuts on Sunday September 24, 2017 @02:57AM (#15323639)
I kind of feel like the web and all that's gone into it is similar to all the work that went into the JVM to make it what it is. Kind of ridiculous, the platform we are on and the sheer amount of intelligence and hard work to make it as efficient as it is is astounding. Maybe because constraints breed creativity to do something with the garbage you have. So I honestly think it's better than it's ever been, but at the same time I understand the author's gripes of "This should have been designed with X in mind first and foremost"
Re:It’s time to kill the web app by hutzlibu on Sunday September 24, 2017 @04:43AM (#15323932)
" but at the same time I understand the author's gripes of "This should have been designed with X in mind first and foremost""

Sure thing. If you know exactly what you need and design for that, than the outcome is allways better, than just randomly adding things here and there. So yes, a newly designed web would be something awesome. The thing is just, that it is somewhat complicated to design such a thing in the first place. And then build it. And while you build it, you discover many new things that also absolutely have to go into the design, so you redesign, ...

So in other words, I am curious for his thoughts on a new design and I would welcome it, if it leads to anything. I am just very sceptical, that there is something really awesome and concrete behind it. Vague ideas how to improve things, are allready floating around since the beginning.

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by Joeri on Sunday September 24, 2017 @04:10AM (#15323834)
The whole DOM and script languages in general are ugly? Skip it all and use only WebGL and Wasm.

Congratulations, now your app is inaccessible to screenreaders and doesn’t lay out properly on half the devices of the internet.

On every platform you have to use the native controls to build a good experience, but the web’s problem is that the native controls are the worst of every app ui platform ever made, so we get layer after layer of framework crud trying to hide the fact that html and css are almost completely unsuited for building app ui. I wish they had been a little more broken, because then someone would have had the sense to replace them.

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by hutzlibu on Sunday September 24, 2017 @04:47AM (#15323940)
"Congratulations, now your app is inaccessible to screenreaders and doesn’t lay out properly on half the devices of the internet."

For most cases, it is quite easy, to provide a simple HTML fallback for that. But yes, it is an issue. But if you do program it right, then it does lay out exactly and perfect on EVERY device, like you intented. (as long as it supports webgl)

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by kllrnohj on Sunday September 24, 2017 @03:46AM (#15323779)
> But the way it is today, the web works.

Does it really? What would you hold up as an example of a powerful web app with significant usage?

All the major players these days (like Facebook) get the overwhelming majority of their traffic through their native mobile app, not through their web app. The web's primary stronghold is in publishing platforms (news, articles, etc...), which are not really what you'd call "apps" and indeed they are the one thing the web was actually built for and good at - static(-ish) content.

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by TekMol on Sunday September 24, 2017 @04:03AM (#15323813)

    What would you hold up as an example of a
    powerful web app with significant usage?
The web as a whole is one gigantic web app that works wonderfully. I am using the web all day and for pretty much everything. HN and the linked articles for news. Trello, Github, Upwork for collaboration. FB and Meetup to find an save events I want to attend. Booking.com to find and book hotels. My local railway site for train travel. My local cab site for cab rides. My local public transport site for bus/subway rides. Google flights for flight planning.... I could continue forever. Whenever I need something, I find it on Google and just use it.
Re:It’s time to kill the web app by hutzlibu on Sunday September 24, 2017 @04:04AM (#15323815)
"All the major players these days (like Facebook) get the overwhelming majority of their traffic through their native mobile app"

Source?

And I do not think, there is a sharp line between WebApp and Website. You could say, we are using one right now (even though very primitive) discussing right now - more than "static(-ish) content"

Also most of the other parts of the Web are not really static anymore - highly dynamic, live interaction between the whole world! That's pretty awesome if you think about it. So the Web works and the web is faaaar away from static documents linking each other, what was it's origin.

And with real webapps - well, I believe the big ones are about to come. The underlying technology to really make them usefull, is just about to become stable.

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by kllrnohj on Monday September 25, 2017 @11:22AM (#15331166)
> Source?

https://expandedramblings.com/index.php/facebook-mobile-app-...

Over 50% of facebook users only access it from their mobile devices.

> And I do not think, there is a sharp line between WebApp and Website. You could say, we are using one right now (even though very primitive) discussing right now - more than "static(-ish) content"

You could make that claim but it'd be a tough sell. Sites like this are clearly not what anyone talks about when they say "web app" or extol the virtues of HTML5. This site is static(-ish) content with hyperlinks to go to new static pages. It's not dynamic or highly interactive. Which is part of what makes it great, don't get me wrong. But it's clearly not a candidate for a web app, it's not clamoring for webasm, webgl, or any of those shiny new toys, etc...

> the web is faaaar away from static documents linking each other, what was it's origin.

How do you figure? Most people google something (either via a dumb web form or more commonly via a native app), then click a link to a static page.

Or this site, which is basically just an index page of yesteryear, and is literally just a bunch of static links to other usually static content.

> And with real webapps - well, I believe the big ones are about to come. The underlying technology to really make them usefull, is just about to become stable.

I disagree since the underlying technology really truly doesn't exist. The fundamental basics to making a responsive app still don't exist at all (no cheap concurrency, for example, to say nothing of cheap parallelism).

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by hutzlibu on Monday September 25, 2017 @03:16PM (#15333184)
"> Source? https://expandedramblings.com/index.php/facebook-mobile-app-.... Over 50% of facebook users only access it from"

maybe it is hidden somewhere, but I only read "mobile users only", not "native app" only. So users who access by browser would be in that category as well

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by pendar747 on Sunday September 24, 2017 @07:15AM (#15324283)
I think the fact that most facebook users only access it trough mobile is because of the general shift to mobile. Even most web usage is now on mobile: example source: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2016/11/01/mobile-web-...
Re:It’s time to kill the web app by twe4ked on Sunday September 24, 2017 @03:50AM (#15323782)
> What would you hold up as an example of a powerful web app with significant usage?

Google Docs suite perhaps?

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by kllrnohj on Monday September 25, 2017 @11:29AM (#15331228)
Maybe? Hard to tell since Google Docs on Android at least is a native app not a wrapper around the website and I'd assume that's true on iOS as well.

Similarly Microsoft Office on mobile is a native app, and I can't seem to find good stats for how Office on Windows/Mac compares to the Docs suite on desktop but my guess is that it's not a pretty comparison for Google Docs...

Re:It’s time to kill the web app by krausejj on Sunday September 24, 2017 @11:31AM (#15325052)
also - how do you kill it? i'm not sure you can. thankfully.