News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by Someone on Saturday September 23, 2017 @01:02PM (#15320611)
”To copy the substrate perfectly implies copying perfectly the pattern encoded on it, and hence (since I'm a reductionist) copying perfectly the self”

But if yo copy a living being, you end up with two living beings, each (presumably) with their own self. Some people would argue getting rid of the original is murder (if you assume the original and the copy share a self, it would be mutilation)

I think the way out of this is to not call it copying but moving (you move a body from atoms a pattern buffer and from there back to atoms)

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by Smaug123 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @01:14PM (#15320679)
Yep, it would be murder - except that in this thought experiment, I stepped into the transporter of my own free will, and thereby expressly consented to the destruction of one of my selves in the immediate future. It becomes much more interesting if someone is forcibly transported; then I think the moral answer depends on what the transportee believes about their consciousness. Do they believe they'll be murdered, or not? Then I think there's a fair argument to say that the forcible transport is morally evil, or neutral, depending on the two cases.
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by colordrops on Saturday September 23, 2017 @02:54PM (#15321086)
"one of my selves" - the flaw in your logic is revealed by this phrase.
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by Smaug123 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @04:38PM (#15321573)
Not to me, it isn't. Care to elaborate? (Pointing out "there is a flaw in your logic" to someone who has a flaw in their logic is rarely very helpful unless you actually point out the flaw too.)
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by Someone on Sunday September 24, 2017 @10:33AM (#15324839)
If I told you ”I’ll delete you, but don’t worry, we have a backup” would you be worried? I would, even if I knew that backup existed and were convinced you would restore it, and even if that backup already had been restored, and probably even if those copies shared a “self”, because destroying one could destroy part of the memories of the combination.
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by colordrops on Saturday September 23, 2017 @09:14PM (#15322706)
Who are you if you aren't an individual? How can you have multiple selves? What entity is doing the possessing of multiple beings? Do you believe in a soul?
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by Smaug123 on Sunday September 24, 2017 @02:29AM (#15323577)
"Individual" is a word that is usually a pretty descriptive one, but breaks down a bit in this kind of situation; likewise "self". As clarified elsewhere in the thread, we use "self", "me", and so on, to express several different notions: "who I am right now", and also "who I was in the past" and "who I will be in the future".

Nothing is possessing multiple beings, except in the sense of my final paragraph in this comment. "I" is merely a pattern expressed on a physical substrate: a computation being executed, if you like. I don't believe I have some kind of essence that is not completely expressed by my physical state.

If you want a neat shorthand for my position: I am to my body as Mac OS is to the computer I'm currently typing on. There can in principle be different incarnations of Mac OS running on different computers (indeed, there are thousands! Every Mac is running a different incarnation of Mac OS right now), but the one which is running on the computer I'm currently using is unique because it's diverged from the master copy that was imprinted on it by the install process. In that sense, Mac OS is the abstract entity possessing multiple computers, though each instance of that entity is different from all the others; Mac OS has multiple "selves". In the teleporting-by-copy analogy, "take a backup image" is the process of scanning matter ready for transmission and disassembly; "install that backup onto a new computer" is the process of recreating my body; "destroy the original computer" is the process of destroying the original body.

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by colordrops on Sunday September 24, 2017 @12:20PM (#15325291)
You are still alluding to the concept of a non-physical layer of reality, the concept of the platonic ideal. There is no "abstract MacOS" floating out in the ether that all your computers have diverged from, unless you believe in a soul or platonic ideal. There are only individual computers with operating systems that happen to look similar to our flawed senses. The abstraction that they are all instantiations of some original is in your head, not a fundamental aspect of reality. Abstractions are a feature of the mind.

Furthermore, the human body is not digital, and not encoded in numbers. You can't completely copy all properties - you would have to change some properties, for instance location in space.

Is something more "you" or less "you" based on how much it has diverged from the original? Thats just absurd.

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by brador on Saturday September 23, 2017 @03:01PM (#15321115)
Can a "pattern recorded on a physical substrate" consent? What does this even mean?
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by Smaug123 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @04:40PM (#15321583)
What does it mean for you to consent? It means that. According to the worldview I have been expounding, I'm "just" a really complicated program running on wildly convoluted wetware. Whatever it means for a person to consent to something, is what it means for that pattern to consent.