News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by gnaritas on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:10PM (#15320332)
> Teleportation in principle is not a death sentence if (like me) you're a reductionist who believes that the mind is a pattern which happens to be encoded on a physical substrate. To copy the substrate perfectly implies copying perfectly the pattern encoded on it, and hence (since I'm a reductionist) copying perfectly the self.

A copy of you is not you, one need only not destroy the original for you to quickly admit that the copy is not you. If I copy you, and ask you if the copy over there is you, you'll say no. If I then kill you, you have just been sentenced to death. The copy will live on feeling as if it is you, but it isn't you, it's a copy of you. That is unless you believe there can be any number of you; but the second they're created they are by definition no longer you, they are them, and your experiences are no longer identical, you are instantly separate beings so they are instantly no longer you.

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by Smaug123 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:14PM (#15320351)
Here we go :)

Your fundamental misunderstanding of my viewpoint is that there can only ever be one of me. The "copy", as you put it, is also one of me. The two are different people by the time you come to threaten one of them with death, but at the instant of creation of the second, they were the same. They diverged since (just as identical twins would, immediately after their brains began to form in the womb). The question of "which one is me" is meaningless: they are both me, in the sense that they have a common "ancestor" (i.e in the sense that I am who I was five minutes ago), and they are both not me (in the sense that I am not who I was five minutes ago).

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by DougWebb on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:32PM (#15320432)
Your "five minutes ago" consciousness would continue along in the original body, and would have the sense of being the same person. The copy would have that sense as well. If both copies are aware of the copying process and which one is the copy, then they could agree that the original is the original "you". But if the copying process destroys one and makes two, or in some other way makes it impossible to distinguish original from copy, then both people could legitimately claim to be the original, and to have a continuous conscious experience of being the original.

That'd be kind of messed up.

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by Smaug123 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:38PM (#15320459)
Basically right, yep :) although personally, my "descendants" wouldn't consider the question of "am I the original?" to be either meaningful or interesting. Both are the original (both descended from the same source through time) and both are not the original (both have diverged from the same source over time).
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by superrad on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:49PM (#15320535)
They might be concerned that one of 'you' had their consciousness terminated prematurely, if only for them wondering on the next transport if they get to continue experiencing life as 'you'.
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by gnaritas on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:17PM (#15320363)
You're just playing a semantic game with the word "me" and "self". Saying they are both me and they are both not me is saying nothing, it's a meaningless statement devoid if any value to communicate anything at all. Put the semantics aside, and try and address the actual underlying issue, identity. The second a clone exists, they are unique individuals, they cannot both be you anymore.
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by Smaug123 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:25PM (#15320404)
Fine. But it's not really a surprise that the language becomes inadequate when the situation becomes extraordinary: the verb "to be" was never built to cover situations where a single entity bifurcates into two identical copies of itself, and you want to track the relationship between the children and the parent.

> A copy of you is not you; one need only not destroy the original for you to quickly admit that the copy is not you.

We're not allowed to play semantics, so this statement is meaningless: you need to play semantics if you want to use the word "is" in this context.

> If I copy you, and ask you if the copy over there is you, you'll say no.

Correct. This is using the word "is" in the same sense as I would if I said that I am no longer who I was five years ago.

> If I then kill you, you have just been sentenced to death. To be precise, someone has just been sentenced to death who was once the Smaug123-who-is-typing-this-now. The one who was killed would say "I have been sentenced to death". The one who was not killed would say "someone else has been sentenced to death".

> The copy will live on feeling as if it is you, but it isn't you, it's a copy of you.

Now who's playing semantic games ;) this time, you're using the word "you" in a different sense to me. Again, "you" refers to two concepts here: the timeless "Smaug123 who is always the same person", and the individual "Smaug123 who can vary over time".

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by gnaritas on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:29PM (#15320423)
> We're not allowed to play semantics, so this statement is meaningless: you need to play semantics if you want to use the word "is" in this context.

That was not remotely a semantic game and I find this statement so absurdly intellectually dishonest that I'm done with this conversation.

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by usjehshksish on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:23PM (#15320391)
A lot of fiction that deals with consciousness copies finds that copies are far more willing to "die" knowing that another instance of the pattern will live on.

Ultimately our desire for self-preservation itself only comes from our evolutionary history. That desire itself is mutable, and you could expect that the portion of it that cares about being the original would slowly evolve away if transporter use were a significant component of the fitness function.

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by gnaritas on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:25PM (#15320405)
It's fiction, it doesn't find anything, it asserts. There's no rational reason at all to think a copy would be more willing to die. We have copies in the real word, twins, and being a twin doesn't make the other have less of a survival instinct.
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by usjehshksish on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:39PM (#15320468)
Twins are copies? You are stretching a bit, I think. I understand you feel strongly about this, but you're not going to convince anyone with weak arguments like this. But, thanks for helping make my intent clearer.

There isn't frequently a situation in reality where a reduction in self preservation would be favored, even in the case of twins. Although I'd bet you would in fact find that twins express a moderately greater willingness to die for one another than other types of siblings.

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by gnaritas on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:49PM (#15320533)
Twins are the closest thing to an exact copy that exist in the real world, that's not remotely stretching, it's trying to ground it reality to make the silliness of the fiction obvious. Like all analogies, it's flawed, try and see the point rather than pick on the flaw. Uh no I don't feel "strongly" about a conversation about identity vs equality of Star Trek transporters, you're projecting. And dying for the love of another isn't remotely the same thing as your original statement, you've moved the goal post.
Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by Smaug123 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @01:05PM (#15320629)
The point is that the analogy actually shows the opposite of what you want it to show! Family members are very, very weak copies of each other, and they still sacrifice themselves to save other family members. Explicitly, we have weak evidence against "There's no rational reason at all to think a copy would be more willing to die", namely that the better the copy of you, the more likely you are to sacrifice yourself for them. (Would an average human be more willing to die for their third cousin twice removed, their aunt, or their father?) The evidence is weak, naturally, because nature doesn't contain anything even remotely like two exact copies of a person; all we can do is attempt to extrapolate from the obvious trend that "the closer the relation, the more willing I am to die for them", and the obvious extrapolation is "the closest possible relation - the exact copy - is the most likely candidate for me to sacrifice myself to save".

By the way, the reason I downvoted your comment was because of the "you're projecting", which comes across as snarky and is not remotely implied by the parent comment.

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by Smaug123 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:28PM (#15320420)
Twins are very low-fidelity copies of each other. They may have been diverging for decades. To use them as counterexamples is dubious at best. (Not disagreeing with your point, but your example is not really evidence in favour of it.)

EDIT: actually, I think you may have provided weak evidence against your assertion. It's not wildly unusual for a family member to sacrifice themself to save other family members from death.

Re:Is beaming down in Star Trek a death sentence? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:50PM (#15320539)
Nor is it unusual for people to sacrifice themselves for communities, nations, or even ideologies. "Self" is not as narrow a concept as naive philosophies assert.