News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by Mediterraneo10 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @09:38AM (#15319667)
As someone from Romania, I see this as a distribution problem and a consequence of consumer apathy. If you live in a few major urban centers, you can buy high-quality food, often the same products as in Western Europe, and the prices are within reach of the average city-dweller. The problem is that in smaller towns, the sole supermarket or two might source only lower-quality products, so you cannot buy better things no matter how much you want to or how much money you are willing to spend.

Wanting a quieter working environment, I recently moved from a big city to a village. The biggest shock for me is how bad the food that is sold here is. Village shops typically buy all their products from a wholesale store like Macro, sometimes the inferior versions of Western European brands, or often the generic brand. The tomato sauce is mostly sugar and food colouring, the chocolate has no actual chocolate in it, and these products are sold at the same prices as the high-quality food in the cities, so it is not a simple matter of rural people not being able to afford better. The people just accept what they get, and none of my new neighbours understands why I would complain.

So, while it may seem unfair to blame the bad food on the people who are the victims of it, if there were more concern from the rural/small-town Romanian public about their food, there might be room for competition and distributors would change to serve them.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by alt_f4 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:21AM (#15320121)
You are wrong. In the few major urban centers, you can buy the most expensive and supposedly high-quality food, but that food is still MUCH LOWER QUALITY than the one sold in Western Europe. And we're talking international brand names here too. E.g., for example, soft drinks and candy bars would be sold with HFCS instead of sugar, chocolate will have lower % cocoa. You will find artificial colorings, preservatives and, generally, all kinds of artificial flavor improvers over healthier, more natural ingredients that are found in the Western versions of the same products of the same brand names. And don't get me started on the quality of meat...

If you haven't noticed that, it is possible you just haven't travelled enough. I've lived for years in both Western and Eastern Europe, so I can tell you -- the differences are very stark and, IMHO, should be illegal.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by virtuabhi on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:22AM (#15320122)
> for example, soft drinks and candy bars would be sold with HFCS instead of sugar, chocolate will have lower % cocoa. You will find artificial colorings, preservatives and, generally, all kinds of artificial flavor improvers over healthier, more natural ingredients that are found in the Western versions of the same products of the same brand names.

Are you talking about USA?

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by alt_f4 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:24AM (#15320132)
Nope, but it is generally well known to us, Europeans, that a lot of the food sold in the US is of lower quality, which is contributing to the US obesity epidemic, cancer rates, heart issues... This is starting to become a problem here too.
Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by faster on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:44AM (#15320222)
When I returned to the US after living in Western Europe, the hardest thing to adapt to was the quality of food in the supermarkets. I left the first two grocery stores empty-handed because nothing looked like food to me. It was all cardboard and plastic and sugar in all its various forms.

However, high quality food is available, but it requires time (to go where it is, since it isn't always distributed like the plastic-wrapped sugar stuff) and money, though not always more than the stores charge for mass-produced things.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by alt_f4 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:53AM (#15320263)
In the US, unlike most cities in Eastern Europe, you at least have the option to pay a premium and get high quality food.
Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by Mediterraneo10 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:31AM (#15320163)
> that food is still MUCH LOWER QUALITY than the one sold in Western Europe

It depends where you shop. A Profi will sell low-quality products regardless of whether it is in a big city or a small town. On the other hand, only in the big city can you shop at Mega Image, which sells a lot of products identical to their Western European versions. Its distribution network is much better than any of the competition. Carrefour and Auchan's more expensive generic brands are identical to that sold in the West (their cheaper generic brands, however, are such crap I don’t even know who would buy it). Meat, I don’t know because I don’t eat it.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by alt_f4 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:38AM (#15320197)
> It depends where you shop

It does not.

You're not getting my point. You go to a Profi or Mega Image and you buy a Milka chocolate, it is the same Milka chocolate because there is only 1 distributor and this is the version of Milka chocolate that gets manufactured for Romania, Bulgaria, etc. And it's shit - it has less cocoa, it is 90g instead of 100g, it is filled with sugar substitutes.

You go to Germany, to an EDEKA or a REWE, and you buy the same Milk chocolate - it has higher % cocoa, it is 100g, it contains milk, cocoa and sugar, no chemical substitutes.

I can make the exact same point for soft drinks and pretty much all packaged goods. Hell, even things like laundry detergents are diluted compared to their western counterparts.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by Mediterraneo10 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:41AM (#15320210)
The whole point of going to a Mega Image is that you don’t have to buy a Milka. Instead, you can buy a Western European chocolate brand in its original Western European version, and for not significantly more money than that Milka would cost in a Profi or village shop.

Similarly, at a Carrefour or Auchan you could buy the generic-label chocolate, which is just the French version with a Romanian ingredients sticker pasted on it, for the same price as a Milka.

People in big cities have access to plenty of high-quality products if they just take advantage of that opportunity and ignore stuff like your Milka example. It is people in small towns and villages who are forced to buy shit food.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by alt_f4 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:47AM (#15320234)
Yeah and that is what people have been doing. But it's a pretty sad state of affairs when the best chocolate you can get is generic-label chocolate from Carrefour. Or, if you're lucky enough to live around one / can afford to shop at a place that imports foreign products from UK / Germany outside of the regular distributor network.

On the other hand, in Germany, you can buy a Milka pretty much anywhere and it is a good chocolate.

Also, this is not really about Milka, it is about thousands of products across dozens of categories, so we can't just ignore this as an isolated, one-off issue. That is why people are pissed.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by zzzcpan on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:39AM (#15320200)
I think you are over generalizing. Local brands in Eastern Europe sell pretty high-quality food, but they sell it cheaper and don't make as much profit on it, than in Western Europe. Non-local brands, on the other hand, sometimes substitute their products with lower quality crap.
Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by alt_f4 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:42AM (#15320215)
> Local brands in Eastern Europe sell pretty high-quality food

any examples?

> Non-local brands, on the other hand, sometimes substitute their products with lower quality crap

change 'sometimes' to 'very frequently' and that would be correct

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by maxerickson on Saturday September 23, 2017 @09:47AM (#15319694)
How big is the village?

Here in the US, this county of ~30,000 has 3 large supermarkets and many smaller grocers. The 10-15 miles distance to the supermarket means that the smaller places can't get away with selling total crap (it's rather rural, so people mostly have cars). The supermarkets all have store brands with decent quality and several national brands for most items.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by Mediterraneo10 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @09:54AM (#15319723)
I couldn’t actually tell you how many people live in this village or the whole comună of which it is a part. However, even being 10–15 km away from the nearest two larger towns does not help, because those two towns have only supermarket chains that are known for lower-quality products and inferior versions of Western European brands. If you really want a large selection of high-quality food, you would have to travel 60 km to the nearest major city, and that is too far for anyone’s regular shopping.

Having been to the US and spent time in some rural areas (I did work-and-travel in Alabama years ago), I would not be so quick to claim that your supermarkets have "decent quality". Most supermarket food in the US is much closer to the bad stuff I find in my village shop than the higher quality food you would find in Western Europe or the largest Romanian cities. But perhaps that is a topic for another thread.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by maxerickson on Saturday September 23, 2017 @10:05AM (#15319773)
There's no fake chocolate being sold as chocolate or tomato sauce with food coloring in it. Perhaps I read too far into hyperbole?
Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by SomeStupidPoint on Saturday September 23, 2017 @10:21AM (#15319857)
> fake chocolate being sold as chocolate

A bunch of candy products have switched to being "chocolate flavored candy". Most candy in the US is total crap, because they've cut out all the parts that make it good to save money.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by maxerickson on Saturday September 23, 2017 @10:27AM (#15319874)
Sure, despite having a sweet tooth I don't enjoy the majority of candy available here. But my phrasing holds up, even in Walmart you can read the packaging and find real dark chocolate (they stock https://www.ghirardelli.com/dark-chocolate-86-cacao-bar-(317... ).
Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by adventured on Saturday September 23, 2017 @10:35AM (#15319912)
> Most candy in the US is total crap, because they've cut out all the parts that make it good to save money.

That's almost entirely a myth. Along with the myth that most of the cheese sold in the US is "American Cheese" or "cheese product." These are fantasy lines of attack on the US for people looking for an excuse to bash.

Here are two more of those myths: the US only sells mediocre, watered down beer (that one has long since been destroyed, it rarely gets used now); and the US doesn't make any good domestic wine that is competitive with eg French wine.

The average Walmart (a mid to lower tier grocery) has a large, normal selection for real chocolate of all varieties (including European). Typically they will have a large half aisle filled with real chocolate candy products to choose from.

The US is the world's largest market for real chocolate.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by Mediterraneo10 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:13AM (#15320089)
> the US only sells mediocre, watered down beer (that one has long since been destroyed, it rarely gets used now)

I think that one isn't used so much because people hear that many American regions now have interesting microbrewery scenes. However, the major national brands are mediocre and watered down compared to many national German or Czech brands (that is the whole reason American regional microbreweries have been able to compete).

> a large, normal selection for real chocolate of all varieties (including European)

That European chocolate in American supermarkets is quite often the lowest-quality stuff from here. For example, Milka. My friends and I spent a lot of time laughing at what American supermarkets think is worth importing. You also see the same thing in India: the worst of European chocolate sold as some exotic, special product, but I would never touch that stuff at home.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by andrioni on Saturday September 23, 2017 @01:35PM (#15320761)
>That European chocolate in American supermarkets is quite often the lowest-quality stuff from here.

I guess this is somewhat universal: the only Brazilian cachaças available here in Germany are the worst ones in Brazil, but they have insane prices (e.g. 12€ for one that isn't worth the 2€ it costs in Brazil).

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by SomeStupidPoint on Saturday September 23, 2017 @06:18PM (#15322086)
I think it's actually extremely universal -- most of the US brands available in Thailand were the more national/mediocre brands.

Which makes sense when you think who is prepared to export levels of product sufficient to supply a nation, but it's amusing that all we really see is the mediocre versions of other nations imported.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by bitL on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:31AM (#15320164)
You get plenty of Lindt in the US. Can't get much better than that...
Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by rayiner on Saturday September 23, 2017 @10:46AM (#15319960)
Wal-Mart is pretty crap on produce and meat, but they’re good at shelf stable stuff like chocolate. The one near me has, as you say, half an aisle of chocolate product of all kinds.
Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by ohyes on Saturday September 23, 2017 @10:27AM (#15319879)
I suspect this is true in any rural area. Alabama is our version of rural Romania. The population density doesn't support the economy of scale required to make daily fresh produce profitable. So you get frozen/canned/otherwise preserved products. If it were profitable, someone would do it.

You go to a more populated area in the US (basically any major metro), you can get the good stuff fairly easily.

We also have 'food deserts' in poorer urban centers (certain cities in Alabama could qualify). I don't have an explanation for those, I think it has to do with poverty.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by cat199 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:53AM (#15320259)
> The population density doesn't support the economy of scale required to make daily fresh produce profitable.

Yet strangely, before mass-market supermarkets existed, people in rural areas ate fresh produce directly from farmers without having such 'economy of scale'.. and the people in the city had trouble accessing them..

when the 'economy of scale' is devoured by the middlemen creating it, it is neither economical nor scalable..

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by Mediterraneo10 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @12:21PM (#15320383)
> Yet strangely, before mass-market supermarkets existed, people in rural areas ate fresh produce directly from farmers

Before mass-market supermarkets existed, rural people ate fresh produce often only because they grew it themselves, not because they were able to buy it direct from a farmer. To buy from a farmer, you need cash, and a lot of rural families were cash-poor. Instead, people in the countryside maintained their own gardens and they made a lot of pickled foods for the winter. However, that is all a lot of work, and in fact historically a lot of rural families had poor nutrition in terms of fresh vegetables in spite of living in the regions that these vegetables came from.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by maxerickson on Saturday September 23, 2017 @10:39AM (#15319931)
Food deserts are places where people mostly have cars and drive to the store.

It's a bad situation for people that don't have cars, but for people with cars, 2 or 3 miles to a grocer is irrelevant.

In Detroit, roughly 90% of households have at least 1 vehicle:

https://datausa.io/profile/geo/detroit-mi/#category_transpor...

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by rayiner on Saturday September 23, 2017 @10:33AM (#15319898)
Even in metro areas the major chains are terrible. But we’re also less willing to pay more for food compared to Western Europe.
Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by norswap on Saturday September 23, 2017 @09:56AM (#15319728)
Probably much much less.

My municipality (in Belgium) is not considered small in any aspect, and yet it actually consists of three historical villages.

My grandparents have a house in the southern of France, and that village/municipality has ~320 residents.

Re:Readers on food inequality in eastern Europe by stefantalpalaru on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:26AM (#15320141)
> If you live in a few major urban centers, you can buy high-quality food, often the same products as in Western Europe

Don't take that for granted. Some of the Italian pasta sold in Romania would not be eaten in Italy: http://stirileprotv.ro/standard-pentru-est/marea-diferenta-d...

In Italy, pasta is made from durum wheat, water and - for some northern pasta types - eggs. Nothing else. Not cheaper common wheat like in Romania, not extra vitamins, minerals or even precooking like in US.