News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by klodolph on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @07:36AM (#1531750)
It sounds like Haskell just isn't your style, but you're saying that Haskell is bad for "real-world" programming. And it sounds like you've never really used Haskell seriously (just a guess, most Haskellers I've met get over their monad fixation within a few months, yet you describe them as "artillery"). If you like Clojure so much, why not go champion that instead of complaining about Haskell?

Besides, if you use "how easy is it to implement 'memoize'" as a benchmark then you'll always end up choosing a Lisp.

Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by yason on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @10:38AM (#1532180)
It's not the style; it's the real world where Haskell and me have never got together very well.

I would like to write in the concise, immutable, lazy, functional, and strongly typed style of Haskell and that's fine with (nontrivial) toy programs and interesting algorithm implementations, but it's the real world requirements and state management where I've always found Haskell unnecessarily burdensome to deal with.

My benchmark for any language is, as a visual person, to first get stuff on the screen and then get it moving. With Haskell I always end up writing more code to deal with the state than I would like to. And by judging other people's code to do similar things (like a vector graphics on the screen in a game or demo) it doesn't seem to get too pretty there either.

Haskell would be a more practical and smoother language by a tenfold if it just went ahead and accepted that I want to do impure things occasionally, and gave me pragmatic tools to do that. Don't say monads, they feel phony given the simplicity of what I need from them. I chose the word artillery because monads are a Goldbergesque way to achieve writing a pointer to some place in memory.

FYI, I do champion Clojure much more than complain about Haskell, but I occasionally do the latter as well in order to reconsider my criticism. And I retry with Haskell from time to time, to see if the feel of the language would finally make me overcome the resistance.

Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by dasil003 on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @02:24PM (#1532951)
I've spent the last 15 years programming professionally various imperative and object-oriented languages.

I think you're being too harsh on Haskell here. Certainly if you just want to quickly hack something together than Haskell is not optimal. Similarly, if you just want to create a web page that has one dynamic element in it, then a web framework is overkill and you might as well just use an inline PHP script.

But the real challenges in programming are always managing complexity over time. I am far from a Haskell expert, but I am definitely an expert in many types of bugs that programmers experience in the real world. And I feel pretty confident saying that at least 90% of bugs that crop up in the real world programs are due to a mismanagement of state. Different people have developed different techniques to combat this, but pure functional programming is by far the most powerful. The TDD/BDD community often touts testing as a guarantor of quality, but as useful as testing is, it pales in comparison to the assurances of mathematical provable functions.

With Haskell you spend more time developing, but you get the greatest possible assurances that A) your code is bug free and B) it will remain bug free even as the program as a whole changes.

It's absolutely true that most development these days is low-budget high-priority stuff where time to market trumps long-term maintainability. However to suggest that Haskell--the strongest bastion of functional purity, and one of the few places where the mathematics behind computer science are being advanced--should water itself down to be more like 1000 other programming languages designed for getting things done™ is just plain silly. If you don't have use for Haskell's purity than don't use it.

Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by swannodette on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @08:09AM (#1531798)
Supporting Haskell and complaining about Haskell are both valid activities. There's plenty to complain about Clojure. However, the post does point out quite succinctly that while Haskell features might be incredible for simplifying many kinds of problems, it's shocking how many simple problems become staggeringly complex in Haskell.
Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by plinkplonk on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @08:20AM (#1531812)
"while $Language features might be incredible for simplifying many kinds of problems, it's shocking how many simple problems become staggeringly complex in $Language."

Replace "$Language" with almost any computer language in existence and that statement is true (given appropriately chosen values of "simple problems" and "staggeringly complex").

So it reduces to, "For any given language some things are simple and others complex. For other languages what is simple and complex differ".

Not saying much, really.

Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by crc on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @09:05AM (#1531908)
> So it reduces to, "For any given language some things are simple and others complex. For other languages what is simple and complex differ".

Though that might be the case, what doesn't change with languages is what users typically consider as simple problems. So "simple problems" are specific to user expectations, not language features. So I think the parent's point still stands.

Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by plinkplonk on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @09:49AM (#1532027)
"what doesn't change with languages is what users typically consider as simple problems.".

If you meant users of the language (vs users of an app built with the langauge) you are wrong.

Consider Text Processing (awk vs Java , even though Java has Text processing libraries), Distributed Computation (Erlang vs C - though you can do DC with C ) , "close to the metal" coding (C vs Scheme), Continuation Passing Style (again C vs Scheme, with a different "winner"), Array processing (J vs Java), statistical code (R vs C++).

What users consider "simple problems" does change with the language used, contra what you said above.

And just like if you start with "Continuation Passing Style is easy" as a criterion , Scheme beats C, or "customized memory management" makes C win over Scheme, if you use "ease of memoizing a function" as a selection criterion you'll end up with a Lisp (over Haskell or C or Java).

Change the criterion and a different language rises to the top. As I said earlier this isn't saying much.

Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by jimbokun on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @02:06PM (#1532887)
Using this same kind of (Language vs Language) comparison, what are some criteria where Haskell wins?
Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by plinkplonk on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @09:36PM (#1534069)
The point was, to make any language "win", just choose one of its strengths as a deciding criterion and take another language without that feature as a punching bag. So to make Haskell "win", All I have to do is state "monadic programming should be easy" or "effectful programming should be clearly distinguished from the pure functional core by the type system." or "Using typeclasses to structure my code should be trivial"

And Haskell "wins" by default over other languages.

That said, fwiw, in my experience the "sweet spot" of Haskell is in large + heavily algorithmic + complex code bases, where its powerful type system shines. It is very fast without sacrificing abstraction. I've built some large machine learning systems with it and I couldn't be happier.

I know other people who are building trading systems in it and they seem delighted too.

As I said, just my experience and I making no claim about how other languages are losers somehow because they have different goals.

Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by jrockway on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @01:29PM (#1535851)
It is very fast without sacrificing abstraction.

This is what I use it for. My program ends up being as long as Perl, but as fast as C. For me, that's the best of both worlds.

For gluing libraries together, it's not the best, but in the last few months it's gotten quite good. There is hardly anything I want to do that would involve reinventing any wheels that I already have in $other_language.

Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by jimbokun on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @01:46PM (#1535895)
"I've built some large machine learning systems with it and I couldn't be happier."

Does Haskell have good matrix libraries? That seems to be at the core of a lot of machine learning tasks, and when I briefly checked a few years back, I didn't see any Haskell native matrix libraries. I think there were LAPACK bindings, maybe.

Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by plinkplonk on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @01:58PM (#1535931)
"Does Haskell have good matrix libraries?"

Last I checked it didn't. But you can FFI bind to any C/Fortran library of your choice(which is what I did).

Re:Do I really want to be using a language where memoize is ... by gtani on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @06:00PM (#1536686)