Re:Abandoned open source projects
by Slackwise on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:58AM
(#1531612)
> So, would this inactive/status flag provide a significant benefit over editing the name/description/readme?
You can always cram more data into another field, but now you've lost easy access to valuable metadata--this would be a hack, rather than a solution. Proposing for users to use a hack rather than a clean, semantically different, UI element is not good on your part as a designer.
A "Status" field benefits users as repository pages can have a prominent notification of the current status. You can also use it as a flag for searches to avoid having to wade through various abandoned projects before finding one that is being maintained.
And for the GitHub developers, it will provide a valuable statistic. Now they can track the progress and usage of repositories without potentially using assumptions like "Hmm, this repo has not be committed to for X days--could be abandoned?" or having to parse through the description/readme for keywords like "abandoned" or "no longer maintained", etc.
So yes, I would say that this simple metadata field would significantly benefit the users and developers.
You can always cram more data into another field, but now you've lost easy access to valuable metadata--this would be a hack, rather than a solution. Proposing for users to use a hack rather than a clean, semantically different, UI element is not good on your part as a designer.
A "Status" field benefits users as repository pages can have a prominent notification of the current status. You can also use it as a flag for searches to avoid having to wade through various abandoned projects before finding one that is being maintained.
And for the GitHub developers, it will provide a valuable statistic. Now they can track the progress and usage of repositories without potentially using assumptions like "Hmm, this repo has not be committed to for X days--could be abandoned?" or having to parse through the description/readme for keywords like "abandoned" or "no longer maintained", etc.
So yes, I would say that this simple metadata field would significantly benefit the users and developers.