You are essentially asserting that a precondition for ACID in Postgres is that the underlying storage medium (or at least the bits on them) will never suffer permanent failures, and has infinite 9's of availability everywhere in the world, instantly. Then, and only then, can PostgreSQL provide anything resembling seamless consistency.
Sorry, no dice. This is not how distributed systems work in the world outside the walled gardens. I'm a huge proponent of the cloud, but I'm not a huge proponent of things that only work if you rely on the cloud.
non-ACID writers like Mongo lose writes routinely, every day, often without anybody noticing. There are no guarantees whatsoever about data integrity. ACID writers lose data in 6-sigma catastrophic failures only, and you can control how many sigmas by tuning durability.
You asked a question about HA configurations so I answered in terms of HA configurations. Serving durable HA storage is literally what dynamo/riak is for. "The write operation is durable. dw (durable write quorum) is a configuration setting used to specify how many replicas to commit to durable storage before returning a successful response." https://stackoverflow.com/questions/22736821/riak-database-a...
Anyway I'm interested in continuing to discuss this if you are because this is a subject I am beginning to write about as part of my startup. so this conversation helps me. Perhaps there is a better medium though if you would like to continue?