Re:High Ground Maneuver (Scott Adams on the iPhone 4 press c...
by wvenable on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @12:21AM
(#1531147)
I'd say in the iPhone case, it's a design trade off. If you just look at the antenna alone, you might claim it's negligent but in the context of the entire device is just a minor design trade off. The idea that it's a major flaw seems pretty unwarranted. I've had phones with major flaws, this is nothing.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:High Ground Maneuver (Scott Adams on the iPhone 4 press c...
by nailer on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @08:00AM
(#1531779)
Not being able to use a phone to make phone calls, when held in a normal way, is a major flaw.
Other phones put their antennas in the base for a reason - the hand doesn't cover the whole area. Try as I can, I cannot replicate the problem holding an HTC Desire in a normal, comfortable grip.
Re:High Ground Maneuver (Scott Adams on the iPhone 4 press c...
by khafra on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @08:08AM
(#1531791)
Keep in mind that your anecdotal experience with the HTC carries very little weight; I tried covering the iPhone 4 gap with my hand in areas with one bar, two bars, and three bars of coverage, and couldn't produce a visible drop--and that was specifically using an abnormal, uncomfortable grip to observe the problem.