News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High Ground Maneuver (Scott Adams on the iPhone 4 press c... by zmmmmm on Monday July 19, 2010 @10:34PM (#1530977)
That's a false dichotomy. It can still be better than a 3gs overall AND have a serious design flaw. Technology has moved on and made the 3gs obsolete in so many ways that it can easily move the overall experience to a new high watermark while still having a serious flaw.
Re:High Ground Maneuver (Scott Adams on the iPhone 4 press c... by wvenable on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @12:27AM (#1531159)
If it gets better reception than the 3GS in some situations and worse in other situations, how is that a serious design flaw? What makes it a flaw rather than simply a design trade off?

I've had many high tech devices way more flawed than this and they didn't get 22 days of coverage, a press conference by the CEO, or some free fixes. Hell exploding laptop batteries got less coverage than this! I don't even own a iPhone (and don't intend to get one) but these comments are over the top.

Re:High Ground Maneuver (Scott Adams on the iPhone 4 press c... by ericd on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @12:47AM (#1531185)
The parent said it was a badly designed phone, I was just saying that since everyone seems to be much happier with it than the predecessor, even in the area of the flaw, it's not a bad design. I don't see a false dichotomy.

And the 3GS is not a completely obsolete phone at all, except by gadget addict standards.