Re:When Dissent Became Treason
by wildmusings on Thursday September 21, 2017 @08:13PM
(#15308381)
>I think "fighting words" is still a real thing in this sense: If I go into a bar, and say the wrong thing about someone's mother, the law is not going to be surprised that they throw a punch at me.
You're incredibly mistaken, and if you act on this misinformation, you're going to find yourself in prison for assault and battery. The "fighting words" doctrine has been repeatedly narrowed over time by subsequent decisions (and may not even exist anymore), and never excused any violence in the first place. It was an exception to free speech, not the provisions in the criminal code that prohibit violence.
Re:When Dissent Became Treason
by trynumber9 on Thursday September 21, 2017 @08:36PM
(#15308489)
> If I go into a bar, and say the wrong thing about someone's mother
He'll be imprisoned for insulting someone's mother?
Re:When Dissent Became Treason
by wildmusings on Thursday September 21, 2017 @08:47PM
(#15308562)
Think a little more broadly here. If he thinks that someone would be justified in throwing a punch if he insults their mother, then he presumably thinks that he would be justified in throwing a punch in the opposite situation.
I think "fighting words" is still a real thing in this sense: If I go into a bar, and say the wrong thing about someone's mother, the law is not going to be surprised that they throw a punch at me.
But in our current culture, it has to be narrow. Otherwise, Antifa is going to claim "fighting words" justifies them brawling in the streets. And, legally, it does not justify it at all.