Re:When Dissent Became Treason
by splintercell on Thursday September 21, 2017 @06:26PM
(#15307876)
> It's not protected if you lie when you shout it. The risk of injury to others is possible either way, but your intent is what protects you.
Falsely shouting fire in a crowded theater is ALSO protected by first amendment (Supreme Court reversed their opinion in 1969 btw). I clarified more in this other comment[1].
The case you cited is an example that we already have limitations on free speech. That case is tragic from my perspective because I would likely try to petition people to avoid a draft, too, should it happen now.
Nitpick: "shouting fire in a theater" is protected speech. It's not protected if you lie when you shout it. The risk of injury to others is possible either way, but your intent is what protects you.