Re:Why Wages Aren’t Growing
by danans on Thursday September 21, 2017 @05:47PM
(#15307645)
This is something Robert Reich wrote about in his books, but he described it in terms of a postwar "pact" between labor and management wherein in exchange for stability in labor availability (no strikes and revolts), management would accede to unions' demands for living wages and other benefits for workers.
The idea was that this provided a mutual benefit for both sides by enabling both growth and predictability. As another benefit, better pay allowed workers to increase their own consumption of goods, which also fueled growth, continuing a pattern stretching back at least as far as Henry Ford.
But according to Mark Blyth, the result of this was major inflation, caused by a positive feedback between between the cost of labor and the cost of goods. This inflation was great for debtors (predominantly labor), who saw the real size of their debts (mostly mortgages) whittled down [1], but bad for creditors (predominantly capitalists), who saw the value of the debt as an asset crumble.
Blyth claims that the globalist system was fashioned by the creditor class to hobble inflation by lowering the costs of production by lowering trade barriers and allowing goods to be produced in the places that could do so at the lowest cost. The idea was that it would simultaneously lower the cost of goods and labor, while also checking inflation, creating a more favorable situation for the debt owned by creditors.
The upside of this has been a dramatic reduction in the number of people living in poverty globally, especially in Asia. But there were unintended(?) consequences, including the demise of entire US domestic economic sectors (i.e. textiles) that used low skilled labor.
The part that segues with the demise of Communism was that at the time (the 80s), there was growing belief among labor that the advocacy of unions was unnecessary, that they could get by, and perhaps even do better, as individuals without such organizations fighting for them.
This probably was and is true for certain industries where workers inherently had more power due to either the uniqueness of their skill-sets or some other factor. But for a lot of workers, this has not been the case, and their total compensation as employees has diminished over time. This doesn't even consider the situation with the growing segment of lower-skilled "gig" contract workers.
[1] As a corollary, those who couldn't get favorable mortgages in those days due to the systemic biases at play was not able to participate in this upside of inflation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining
The idea was that this provided a mutual benefit for both sides by enabling both growth and predictability. As another benefit, better pay allowed workers to increase their own consumption of goods, which also fueled growth, continuing a pattern stretching back at least as far as Henry Ford.
But according to Mark Blyth, the result of this was major inflation, caused by a positive feedback between between the cost of labor and the cost of goods. This inflation was great for debtors (predominantly labor), who saw the real size of their debts (mostly mortgages) whittled down [1], but bad for creditors (predominantly capitalists), who saw the value of the debt as an asset crumble.
Blyth claims that the globalist system was fashioned by the creditor class to hobble inflation by lowering the costs of production by lowering trade barriers and allowing goods to be produced in the places that could do so at the lowest cost. The idea was that it would simultaneously lower the cost of goods and labor, while also checking inflation, creating a more favorable situation for the debt owned by creditors.
The upside of this has been a dramatic reduction in the number of people living in poverty globally, especially in Asia. But there were unintended(?) consequences, including the demise of entire US domestic economic sectors (i.e. textiles) that used low skilled labor.
The part that segues with the demise of Communism was that at the time (the 80s), there was growing belief among labor that the advocacy of unions was unnecessary, that they could get by, and perhaps even do better, as individuals without such organizations fighting for them.
This probably was and is true for certain industries where workers inherently had more power due to either the uniqueness of their skill-sets or some other factor. But for a lot of workers, this has not been the case, and their total compensation as employees has diminished over time. This doesn't even consider the situation with the growing segment of lower-skilled "gig" contract workers.
[1] As a corollary, those who couldn't get favorable mortgages in those days due to the systemic biases at play was not able to participate in this upside of inflation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining