I can't say whether Equifax's agreement with the bank provides any clauses to allow for revocation of Equifax rights to store the information about me, but if it does not then I need to go out and find me a new bank with some better lawyers.
(I'm saying that a scenario such as this whole series of negligent behavior and events, should trigger one of those clauses.)
You are trying to draw boundaries that don't exist.
Shouldn't they have some kind of licensing requirement in order to be held accountable for their security practices? Where is the line, that when they cross it, they should lose their accreditation? There isn't one, because there is no such accreditation (not to my knowledge anyway.)
It is not reasonable if there are only 3 credit reporting agencies and they do not have any licensing requirements. If I am mistaken about this, please correct me.
But as of now, those requirements don't apply to them. So acting like they do is distracting at best.
Let's figure out ways: a) to know what they have, b) to force them to accept corrections, and c) add major negative consequences if/when they f* up.
If 140MM Americans (or even 50MM, let's be reasonable) told Equifax that they wanted to be removed from their database in response to the breach, and Equifax was required to honor those requests, it would be a step in the right direction.
That would be enough to put some "fear of God" into the shareholders at the remaining credit reporting agencies, and it does not sound like an unreasonable request at all. Companies going forward would have a disincentive to do business with Equifax, because 1/3 of people are missing from their database. (Instead, we're all permitted to buy more "Credit Freeze and Monitoring" solutions from Equifax, for the low price of $0, plus a low low payment of $10 every time we need to freeze or unfreeze our credit again to access it in the future. So let's dig the hole even deeper!)
Citizens that want to have credit would not be incentivized to remove their credit history from all three reporting agencies; as you probably already know, having no credit history is worse than having a bad credit history.
Then again, if we allowed that, then what's to stop those hackers from benevolently making the request on behalf of all 140MM people whose information they have appropriated.
There is no negative consequence that will incentivize Equifax to do better next time, if the result of this breach and their subsequent bungling of the response, is that they are allowed to continue operating their business without interruption.
Take the keys to the car away from the drunk driver. That's step one.
Im not saying they never had a right to store the data, I'm simply saying that it should be revoked. Let's not give them more responsibility and more data, they've already proven repeatedly that they can't handle it.
Why yes, you did through your agreement with any vendor (e.g. bank, credit union, credit card company, rental) that you have dealt with. This is a standard clause, although some places don't actually do it (my landlord for instance as I found out when I went for a car loan).
I hate this, but claiming you didn't consent is just not a credible answer without some additional legislation to force contracts to be explicit in whom a vendor may share information.