News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Distrustful U.S. allies force spy agency to back down in ... by tptacek on Thursday September 21, 2017 @11:34AM (#15304470)
No, there's no reason to trust the NSA's motivations. I'm just not sure what the NSA's motivations have to do with this.

If you're asking, "do we actually need lightweight ciphers", well, the NSA isn't the only organization designing them; it's a whole field of research. If you want cryptographic security on machines that don't have multipliers and count their capacity for program text space in single-digit kilobytes, you're probably going to reach for special-purpose designs.

Re:Distrustful U.S. allies force spy agency to back down in ... by Programmatic on Thursday September 21, 2017 @12:54PM (#15305331)
Running an algorithm chosen by an attacker with extensive resources is foolhardy, because you can never be certain that your resources are sufficient to detect a trap carefully hidden by their resources. We have a history of the NSA performing attacks and standards subversion. Why accept their potential trojan horse when you can have algorithms designed by those without that checkered past, keep up the same amount of scrutiny for potential trojan horses, and have decreased odds of a backdoor being present if the provider is more trustworthy?

It seems that taking motivations into account could lead you into a false sense of security, but that if you keep up the same amount of security and distrust known bad actors that you increase it.

Re:Distrustful U.S. allies force spy agency to back down in ... by tptacek on Thursday September 21, 2017 @12:55PM (#15305334)
Re:Distrustful U.S. allies force spy agency to back down in ... by throwaway2048 on Thursday September 21, 2017 @12:54PM (#15305333)
The NSA massively violated trust in the technical standards processes, now they get to lay down in their bed.

If your response to this is "don't worry about it, its unlikely these ciphers are backdoored", you are missing the point.

Re:Distrustful U.S. allies force spy agency to back down in ... by tptacek on Thursday September 21, 2017 @12:55PM (#15305340)
This isn't responsive to anything I wrote on this thread. I am interested in talking about cipher design, or about the technical intersection between trust and cipher design. I've already stipulated the politics of the story, which are deeply boring to me. You're addressing arguments I haven't made.