News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by FooHentai on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @09:52PM (#15299985)
It's almost as if there's some mysterious third factor at play, above and beyond giving your customers what they want, and above making a profit.

What could it be? This mysterious additional factor.. What could make the US company with the biggest CPU market share in the world possibly want to put an omnipresent overlord control chip onboard every processor it ships? It's almost like there's some kind of outside force at play, but that's a crazy idea. There's No Simple Answer here, for sure.

What indeed, such a mystery! It's a mystery, I tells ya!

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by jwcacces on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @09:58PM (#15300012)
You're not Intel's customer. Dell, Lenovo, Amazon et al. are. And they want management systems, because the large companies who buy from those guys also want management systems. This isn't some super conspiracy, (even if it's something the three letter organizations try to take advantage of it) this is pure business. Pwning a computer across the internet that your dumbass sales manager left on a train is a feature.
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by FooHentai on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:34AM (#15301022)
In a world where the clipper chip, snowden leaks, NSAKey, room 641a, NSA/RSA deal, and national security letters didn't exist, I'd be in the realms of crazy conspiracy theorist and you'd sound like the rational voice of evidence-based reason.

But that's not the world we live in. What I list above are not conspiracy theories, they are proven, factual happenings. There is a clear evidential basis to infer the NSA's intent and capabilities in this area.

There are obviously security/privacy snafus that companies make all the time that have nothing to do with nation-state influence and spying. Superfish, for example, was more-likely-than-not a really bad judgement call on the tradeoff between analytics and customer privacy.

>this is pure business.

If that were true then the ability to disable ME, which clearly exists, would be made available to parties other than the NSA.

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by Angostura on Thursday September 21, 2017 @06:48AM (#15302129)
... or you know - both are true - Enterprises want remote management - and provide the business case - and TLAs would like it too
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by eivarv on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:51AM (#15301070)
Nah, it's still conspiracy theories. At best conspiracy conjecture.

Unlike "... proven, factual happenings", your idea isn't backed by any evidence - at least not any that appear in your post.

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by FooHentai on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:53AM (#15301075)
What kind of evidence would you imagine one would find, if that were happening?
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by eivarv on Thursday September 21, 2017 @04:17AM (#15301455)
Your point doesn't push the burden of proof unto those that disagree (see Russel's teapot[0]), nor make it OK to skip evidence altogether.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_teapot

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by indrax on Thursday September 21, 2017 @09:03AM (#15302889)
Things change once we've found the rest of a tea set in various orbits. There may not be strong direct evidence but it's no longer a silly conjecture, it's the kind of thing that we find.

So those other examples mean you do have the burden of justifying your 'conspiracy' label.

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by eivarv on Thursday September 21, 2017 @09:36AM (#15303185)
Not really; it isn't actually proven until you have proof.

As FooHentai originally said, "There is a clear evidential basis to infer the NSA's intent and capabilities in this area" - but it tells us nothing about this particular case, which remains speculation. One could say the odds have changed, but we still don't know anything about the real state of things.

The "'conspiracy'-label" is applicable regardless, whether we're talking about fact or fiction.

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by yellowapple on Thursday September 21, 2017 @01:09PM (#15305468)
If you find that someone broke into your house and stole your Xbox, and there's a guy down the street who you already know has a long criminal record of home burglaries, is it unreasonable to suspect that guy to be a likely culprit?

Likewise, if there's a backdoor in every new PC's CPU, and there's a three-letter agency presiding over that CPU vendor's jurisdiction that has a long track record of backdooring things, is it unreasonable to suspect that maybe - just maybe - that TLA is responsible?

Now of course the ex-con or the TLA can be totally innocent here, but if I were a detective, they'd be the first ones from whom I'd be asking for alibis.

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by eivarv on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:02PM (#15305936)
I don't think your analogy holds up;

The hypotheticals aren't comparable, nor is the prior available information - and even though the Intel AMT/ME situation is egregious, explaining it simply as "a backdoor" is an oversimplification.

I'd agree that probabilities with regard to what is reasonable to assume (the operative word here) shift as a consequence of circumstantial information, but you can't really draw any conclusions based on that - hence the burden of proof, i.e. the presumption of innocence in your analogy.

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by BearGoesChirp on Thursday September 21, 2017 @09:24AM (#15303059)
As indrax partly pointed out, Russel's teapot exists in a void where rational entities with no hidden desires are discussing a single fact with perfect knowledge, and no other related facts exist. Reality is filled with humans whose behavior follows trends, and the entirety of science is based on the concept that past evidence applies to the future despite having no evidence it will, because we allow induction since deduction is based on axioms of which we have none.
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by eivarv on Thursday September 21, 2017 @10:18AM (#15303643)
So what is the inductive reasoning behind the alleged conspiracy in question, then?

That it must have happened since the NSA has the intent and capabilities? Does this mean that any digital conspiracy you can dream up involving the NSA is probable?

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by BearGoesChirp on Thursday September 21, 2017 @04:11PM (#15306926)
>Does this mean that any digital conspiracy you can dream up involving the NSA is probable?

No. If I dreamed up that the NSA was using frequencies in CPUs to control our behaviors and increase our orange juice consumption, there are still reasons to not treat that one as having any reasonable probability of being true, compared to the notion that the NSA is working to get back-doors into software. Reasons for this difference in probability are based on feasibility, implications if true, how specific the claim is, and if it is in line with past behaviors.

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by eivarv on Thursday September 21, 2017 @04:37PM (#15307115)
My point is, to follow your example re: orange juice consumption, that the reasons not to treat it as having any reasonable probability is secondary to the fact that there is no supporting evidence (burden of proof, etc.)

As I replied in another subthread, I'd agree that probabilities with regard to what is reasonable to assume (the operative word here) shift as a consequence of circumstantial information, but you can't really draw any conclusions based on that.

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by yellowapple on Thursday September 21, 2017 @01:11PM (#15305487)
"Does this mean that any digital conspiracy you can dream up involving the NSA is probable?"

Um, yes?

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by ss248 on Thursday September 21, 2017 @01:49AM (#15300871)
>And they want management systems

The funny thing is that they actually don't. Never heard of system administrator who prefers to use intel ME. Some people told me that there are better tools to manage computers in the datacenter for example and ime just not worth it.

This is just an anecdata, but if anyone has any stories of using Intel AMT on a large scale (or actually on any scale even), i would really love to hear them.

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by shard on Thursday September 21, 2017 @03:56AM (#15301350)
I don't think system administrators are the customers, they are just the employees who keep the systems running. The customers are the upper management who has final approval on the purchases. The problem is likely that somewhere between the system administrators and the chain of management up to the top, one of the levels don't have enough political clout or was not persuasive enough to convince upper management to take a different direction.
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by TeMPOraL on Thursday September 21, 2017 @07:35AM (#15302343)
This.

I had this situation in my career. Someone somewhere in the management chain decided that all computers need a full remote management tool installed behind employees' backs, and our friendly sysadmins didn't have any say in that; their job is to tell us to not have stuff that the remote management scripts identify as unwanted.

In another place that I had to deal with for a while, someone had the bright idea to outsource IT to an external company. This meant all the computers software engineers used were a) locked up as much as they could be, b) alterations to some OS configuration (or hardware) required going through a third party service provider.

I kind of understand the need for locking things up for regular computer users. I guess it also somehow adds up in the sheets to the upper beancounters. I also believe their math is totally bogus, because it doesn't count in the total destruction of productivity it causes for engineers of all kind.

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by ginreaper on Thursday September 21, 2017 @08:34AM (#15302671)
Yeah. New project at my work is to get everyone onto a stripped down Windows 10 dumb terminal with IE and MS Office installed, no admin rights, no extra software.

I flat out refused to upgrade. I'm a software engineer. You want me catting, grepping and manipulating files on OneCloud ? really?

You want my VMs (also not allowed by default) to be stored in one cloud?

Like... this was clearly not well thought out

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by exikyut on Sunday September 24, 2017 @01:12AM (#15323421)
Think like a lawyer for a minute, consider the kind of work you need to do, and the maximum IOPS, CPU time, memory and diskspace this will all need.

Now go spec out however many AWS instances of the required type(s).

Now CC all-but-the-CTO on an email to accounting in reference to the new upgrade, asking for approval for this resource request.

This will likely result in all kinds of interesting noises and prompt a confused meeting.

"Why do you need all this?!"

"The new machine won't be able to provide these facilities locally."

"Can... can you continue to use your old machine?"

"For a while, sure."

"Well... what's changed? Why can't the new machine work?"

"The new machine won't have local admin, so I won't be able to install arbitrary software."

Insert sounds of manglement choking here. (Why do I feel I'm on TFTS...?)

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by stephengillie on Thursday September 21, 2017 @09:50AM (#15303336)
I've been a system administrator at several large and small companies, including a major cloud host. HN is the only place I've ever heard the Intel ME discussed in my professional career. I would actually like to have access to some of those features to help manage workstations.
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by raverbashing on Thursday September 21, 2017 @05:39AM (#15301860)
Which will be fun when the next data breach happens because of it
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by KGIII on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @10:18PM (#15300102)
The 'best' part about it is that they don't even have to leave it on a train. This is progress!
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by wolco on Thursday September 21, 2017 @01:28AM (#15300802)
You are intel's customer when those retail stores try to sell a computer to yourself. They usually include the cpu details and can help a customer make a decision. That's why the intel inside campaign was so successful.
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by userbinator on Thursday September 21, 2017 @03:23AM (#15301192)
Keyword being "was". Unfortunately most PC (and Mac, to an even greater extent) buyers today probably barely know who makes the CPU in what they're buying.
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by TeMPOraL on Thursday September 21, 2017 @07:37AM (#15302347)
Also the choice is, and always was, basically between Intel and AMD. That's literally two options a customer has. When both companies implement a management engine across their CPUs, you don't have any choice in the matter.
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by r3dk1ng on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:39PM (#15306255)
I've had a handful of computers with CPUs made by VIA, so there's at least a small third option.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VIA_Technologies

Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by OnlineCourage on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @11:55PM (#15300477)
Never Sherlocking A Culpable, Integrated And Feasible Balanced Induction as to what that force may be!
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by FooHentai on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:55AM (#15301087)
Exactly :D
Re:How to hack a turned-off computer, or running unsigned co... by marcosdumay on Thursday September 21, 2017 @11:20AM (#15304326)
It's not only that. There is also that other US company that is the biggest competitor of this one, that will add every feature people want to their cheapest CPUs, will undercut its rivals profit rate, will negotiate customizations with larger clients, and yet refuses to compete on living those undesired features out of some CPU model.

No Simple Answer at all.