News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Startup Competitive Advantages that Work by btilly on Monday July 19, 2010 @01:58PM (#1529520)
What is sad is to see a company with a competitive advantage fail to see it and throw it away.

I used to work at Rent.com. A key competitive advantage is that its revenue cycle is wrong. When it started its competitors all made money as soon as they referred someone. Rent.com only made money after the person was referred, leased, reported it to us, the apartment was contacted, and the apartment paid. Optimizing for this was difficult, but once Rent.com had traction none of its competitors could afford to switch models because that would open them up for apples to apples comparisons, with a company that had already been optimized, when they didn't even know how to track that data!

Then Rent.com got a new, well-funded, competitor called MyNewPlace.com with deep industry connections. Same model. Some people there used to be at Rent.com. Absolutely no idea how to implement. This is where Rent.com should have increased their spend on advertising to the point where the unoptimized upstart was losing money on every sale and Rent.com was making money. Wait until the competitor went under. Then cut back on advertising.

Unfortunately Rent.com had been purchased by eBay, eBay didn't understand Rent.com's business model, and so Rent.com was forced to squeeze margins. This gave MyNewPlace all the time in the world to figure out the business model. Worse yet, Rent.com put someone in charge of internet advertising who completely didn't understand affiliate relationships (even at break-even they are profitable because of positive SEO), and that self-inflicted wound only helped MyNewPlace more.

It was a great competitive advantage. No competitor should have been allowed to flourish. But if you don't understand your competitive advantage, it is easy to throw it away. And they did.

Re:Startup Competitive Advantages that Work by patio11 on Monday July 19, 2010 @03:04PM (#1529751)
even at break-even [affiliates] are profitable because of positive SEO

Not necessarily true in all cases, but broadly accurate. Also, you can work the backend. (Solicit upgrades, upsells, and repeat purchases from the customer, which would typically not result in you paying additional commissions to the affiliate.)

Re:Startup Competitive Advantages that Work by btilly on Monday July 19, 2010 @03:18PM (#1529792)
It was certainly accurate in Rent.com's case. Working the backend is another good idea, but not one that Rent.com used. (Typically once people have found a place to live, they aren't in immediate need of another.)
Re:Startup Competitive Advantages that Work by ebiester on Monday July 19, 2010 @05:05PM (#1530161)
Moving services? New furnishing for that bigger apartment?
Re:Startup Competitive Advantages that Work by btilly on Monday July 19, 2010 @05:29PM (#1530222)
Rent tried those things, but they were never more than small sidelines compared to the main business.
Re:Startup Competitive Advantages that Work by dennisgorelik on Monday July 19, 2010 @05:37PM (#1530251)
It looks like Rent.com still ahead of mynewplace.com http://www.quantcast.com/profile/embed?img=http%3A//www.quan...
Re:Startup Competitive Advantages that Work by presidentender on Monday July 19, 2010 @07:19PM (#1530560)
I think his point is that they could have forced mynewplace out of the market very quickly, and didn't.
Re:Startup Competitive Advantages that Work by btilly on Monday July 19, 2010 @07:46PM (#1530623)
Exactly. And at this point MyNewPlace has figured out enough of what Rent did well to be competitive, and is coming up with new ideas faster.

It doesn't help that most of the team that made Rent what it was in the first place (including me) have moved on. There is a definite loss of institutional knowledge.

Re:Startup Competitive Advantages that Work by ericd on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @12:27AM (#1531160)
This is fascinating. Would you mind talking a bit more about this via email? I can't seem to find your contact info, but mine is in my profile.