News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by CydeWeys on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @10:13AM (#15293914)
Your situation is quite different than recently constructed sidewalks being unsafe to navigate by people with disabilities or the elderly, and lacking such basic features as curb cuts. Don't be so black and white.
Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by TKinNC on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @10:16AM (#15293950)
That is exactly my point. She sues, wins and now EVERYONE is forced to comply to a single standard - regardless of the situation. Don't be so naive.
Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by CydeWeys on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @10:35AM (#15294173)
If the city had done a better job of complying with the existing accessibility laws in the first place then she never would have had to resorting to a lawsuit. Hell, if people had done a better job in the first place those laws would not have been necessary at all, and you wouldn't be affected.
Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by carapace on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:24PM (#15297307)
I'm sympathetic to your situation, it seems kinda messed up.

I think you are exaggerating the issue though.

Ideally, an intelligent and flexible application of the ADA rules could be envisioned.

(Ideally we would prioritize research into regeneration and fix the real problem.)

One of my friends was born quadriplegic and literally cannot live without help. He can't go to the bathroom without help. He can't pick his nose. Traveling around Seattle with him made me realize the fact that accessibility makes us a worthwhile civilization. We care, and spend to show it.

Consider: If you spend ten thousand dollars on accessibility for your barn, and no one ever uses it, that's a good thing.

Pick your nose and count your blessings.

Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by TKinNC on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:36PM (#15297444)
I see your point and I do consider myself very fortunate to not have to deal with a life-altering disability on a daily basis, but the problem is - "flexible" and "intelligent" just do not apply when it comes to most govt. regulation.
Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by carapace on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @07:01PM (#15299123)
Well met. I hope I didn't sound like a jerk.

As for "flexible" and "intelligent" govt. regulation., I'll admit I chuckled when I typed that in. We'll be regrowing limbs long before that, I'll wager.

I'm not sure how to remedy the situation until then. It sucks that you have this extra burden just to use your own barn.

Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by hudibras on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @10:30AM (#15294120)
A single standard that's already required by law. If enough people don't like the law, then they can elect politicians who will change it.
Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by s73ver_ on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @12:14PM (#15295415)
So now everyone benefits from accessibility? I'm still not seeing the problem.
Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by viridian on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @12:18PM (#15295466)
The problem is that business owners are now required to follow these statutes and pay money even if the labor is 100% a guaranteed waste. Having people perform labor that isn't needed and use resources like concrete just to appease the government is a bad thing.
Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by s73ver_ on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @01:08PM (#15296024)
I guess I would have to completely disagree with the idea that it's a "complete waste". And I don't consider accessibility a bad thing.
Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by viridian on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @01:48PM (#15296423)
If no one benefits, then it is a complete waste. If I get paid to write code that never gets used, and it takes me a week, it's a waste of hundreds of dollars of labor. The parent thread pointed out that no disabled person would ever use the upgrade as the property was privately held by non disabled persons, so he's required to pay for no reason. That's nonsense.

edit: Are you retrofitted your entire house to be fully ADA compliant? If not, why should the parent be required to?

Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by CydeWeys on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @02:19PM (#15296723)
Houses are not commercial establishments, and as such are not covered under the ADA. That's the short answer. The parent is creating a commercial establishment.
Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by TKinNC on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:13PM (#15297212)
This is 100% incorrect. A residential structure can still be required to be ADA compliant dependent on use. Do your research.
Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by CydeWeys on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:44PM (#15298047)
I just did my research: https://adata.org/faq/does-ada-cover-private-apartments-and-...

If it's 100% incorrect as you claim, surely you can provide evidence supporting your claim?

Re:The Struggle with Where the Sidewalks Won't Go by TKinNC on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @06:23PM (#15298878)
You don't seem to understand the difference between zoning and use because your link proves my exact point.

A place zoned residential can fall under ADA compliance if the use is commercial. Exactly as that link states. So the first part of your statement "Houses are not commercial establishments" is correct for zoning classification, but you fail on the second half "as such are not covered under the ADA." - a residence operating as a business can be under ADA.

My comment "A residential structure can still be required to be ADA compliant dependent on use." - is 100% correct based on the very evidence you supplied.

At this point, why dont you just accept that this is a very complex topic and one that just maybe I've spent more time navigating than you.