Notably, they didn't offer to cover my time, his time, and the expense of the lawyer. I value my time more than I value money. I consider these things theft of my time.
The nature of debt collection, and many other legal pickles is that if you are seen to be passively ignoring it, then it just ramps up.
Merely asking for proof is indistinguishable from ignoring claims because it leaves no paper trail. You have to actually get documents from them (or from a court) saying that they have no claim. And it costs a lot (whether in time, money or both) to get that.
> You have to actually get documents from them
> (or from a court) saying that they have no claim.
Naturally this varies in different jurisdictions, but generally speaking, the burden of proof is on the person making the claim.If I say that you owe me money, it's not necessary for you to obtain documents (from either me or from a court) stating that you don't owe me money - the onus is on me to _prove_ that you me money.
But you can't ignore it, that's true.
Even if I owe money...why should I pay you? Prove you bought the loans, tomorrow someone else can ask me to pay for it again.
That's an excellent point. The fact that you paid off a fraudster doesn't in any way change the fact that you still owe money to the legitimate owner of the loan. So you need to demand proof that whoever is asking you for payment is the owner of the loan and not a fraudster.
Sounds fishy. The borrower was paying somebody at least up until he defaulted. Would not that entity be the one entitled to try to collect? Or were loans actually in default being sold around?
So some jerk is buying a $50K loan for $1.5K. But trying to collect $50K, plus fees and penalties. And ruining someone's credit in the process.
That's insane.
This sounds a lot like what was happening during the financial crisis a decade ago. Lenders were selling mortgage loans to Wall Street to be bundled into collateralized debt obligations. After those CDOs got sold a few times, people lost track of who actually owned a particular loan. When borrowers defaulted, it was in many cases impossible to prove who was legally entitled to collect on the debt.
(A line in a spreadsheet that says John Doe owes you $500K is not very convincing evidence to a judge - you need to be able to provide a document with John Doe's signature on it.)