News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by bhhaskin on Monday September 18, 2017 @04:25PM (#15279199)
We are allowing large corporations to dictate and push the web toward a closed system. A future where there has to be an App for that, and if you don't keep your head down you will be censored and cutoff from the rest of the online world.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by tdy721 on Monday September 18, 2017 @05:20PM (#15279706)
If you want the masses to care, the masses will have to lose first. They (not hackers) don't get it, and it's inconceivable that they ever will... Until they notice the closed system.

Is there even a war taking place? Battles are often forgotten.

Yes, we (the hackers) allowed this to happen. We need to think about it now. I feel like the YOU in your comment is slightly misaddressed. What can WE do about it?

jus' trolling the good guys...

Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by bhhaskin on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:02PM (#15280081)
Once a system becomes closed it is very difficult to become open again. It's like personal liberty & freedoms, if you/we give them up they are almost impossible to get them back.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by xvilka on Monday September 18, 2017 @09:05PM (#15281037)
Probably it will take a few centuries to realise this, and every single right restriction. People are always bad at protecting their rights.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by 2trill2spill on Monday September 18, 2017 @04:29PM (#15279240)
Hogwash, there is more open source software now then ever before.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by pdonis on Monday September 18, 2017 @04:35PM (#15279284)
What's important is not what software exists somewhere where somebody could theoretically download and use it, but what software actually gets used. Most users don't even know what open source software is, much less where to find any; they use what comes with either Windows or OS X or their smartphone.

Also, your software can be as open source as you like, but if it can't interoperate with the rest of the Internet, it's useless. Personally, I don't watch TV or movies on my computer so I don't particularly care whether my browser lets me do that or not. But I would care very much if, for example, my bank's website started requiring a DRM-capable browser. Open source doesn't address that problem.

Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by cesarb on Monday September 18, 2017 @07:15PM (#15280525)
> But I would care very much if, for example, my bank's website started requiring a DRM-capable browser.

That already is the case for banks which use gbplugin. You have to use that closed-source component, or the online banking website won't even let you login. And it's invasive; I have seen reports of it slowing down the whole computer, conflicting with a Windows update (http://www.linhadefensiva.org/2013/04/teste-mostra-incompati...), and disabling IPv6 (http://ipv6.br/post/bug-em-plugin-de-seguranca-de-bancos-blo...). For a while, it wasn't even available for Linux, so you had to use Windows.

Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by 2trill2spill on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:21PM (#15280204)
> What's important is not what software exists somewhere where somebody could theoretically download and use it, but what software actually gets used. Most users don't even know what open source software is, much less where to find any; they use what comes with either Windows or OS X or their smartphone.

The people who care about the "Open Web" and DRM know about open source software and the people who don't care, don't know about Open Source software precisely because they don't care.

> if, for example, my bank's website started requiring a DRM-capable browser. Open source doesn't address that problem.

That's the banks property (website, servers, etc) you have no say in how they run it, if they go and do something stupid like require DRM to visit their site and you don't want DRM you have to switch banks. You made the choice to not use DRM, so you have to face the consequences of your choice. The bank made the choice of requiring DRM and they have to live with the consequences of customers switching banks. Open Source software was never meant to control others property.

Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by pdonis on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @05:30PM (#15288998)
> if they go and do something stupid like require DRM to visit their site and you don't want DRM you have to switch banks.

But if every bank--or at least every bank I would possibly consider entrusting my money to--requires DRM, because DRM is the standard and all the major browsers use it and the bank doesn't want to go to the trouble of inventing all their own infrastructure just to avoid using DRM, then what bank do I switch to?

> Open Source software was never meant to control others property.

Exactly. So Open Source software does not address the problem I said it does not address. So we are in agreement on that point. Good.

But you were saying, in the post I originally responded to, that Open Source software will somehow prevent the web from becoming effectively a closed system. That would only be the case if Open Source software did address the problem that you and I both agree it does not address.

Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by no_wizard on Monday September 18, 2017 @05:00PM (#15279519)
Its always been this way. I can't remember a time that open source software was front of mind even for those who Ould have had a vested interest in knowing about beyond computer scientists/engineers or their academic counterparts. There are exceptions, no doubt. I think generally though, this has always been the case. End users in particular usually don't know the difference nor do they care to (though as the allegory goes, sometimes they do when its too late. )
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by jononor on Monday September 18, 2017 @05:38PM (#15279856)
Firefox was for a while. OpenOffice also for a short time (especially in schools), before webby things (Google Docs etc) ate it up.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by movedx on Monday September 18, 2017 @05:02PM (#15279544)
> Most users don't even know what open source software is, much less where to find any; they use what comes with either Windows or OS X or their smartphone.

This is an educational issue at the social level. The technology is still available.

Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by tdy721 on Monday September 18, 2017 @05:23PM (#15279722)
Exactly, I don't want a password for my online banking, I actually despise the fact that my bank would ever even ask for one. I want a bank where I can deliver an SSH key.

The tech is here. It's been here all along.

Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by bhhaskin on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:05PM (#15280095)
That would be pretty amazing.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by ethanwillis on Monday September 18, 2017 @04:35PM (#15279283)
Developers are using open source. End users not so much, except open source bundled into their apps as libraries to actually power them.

Getting an app into users hands nowadays is becoming gatekeeped more and more. Either through fearmongering (buy those certs for your apps approved by Gatekeeper X) or literal gatekeeping on app stores.

You can argue that people don't have to use locked down app stores, but then you're just missing the point.

Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by bhhaskin on Monday September 18, 2017 @04:40PM (#15279340)
I couldn't agree more, and on top of that it is getting harder and harder to use open app stores. More and more devices are locked down.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by syshum on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:58PM (#15280430)
Is there though?

There are more open source libraries, tools, frameworks, languages and other tools used to create software

But I am seeing a HUGE shift to Closed off, non open SaaS and property installed apps for end users.

Outside of dev tools I am not seeing a shift to open source.

GPL a licence that protects user freedom has fallen out of favor in place of MIT and BSD which protects developer freedom

So like EME, Open Source has become hostile users. Open Source is for dev's not users

Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by rimliu on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @04:27AM (#15282717)

  > Outside of dev tools I am not seeing a shift to open
  > source.
Because very few open source authors understand end users which are not developers. And comments here prove that.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by 5ilv3r on Monday September 18, 2017 @04:34PM (#15279277)
We have a quality problem, even it there is ample quantity.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by 2trill2spill on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:25PM (#15280225)
Most software, open or closed has quality issues, so while I think your right, I also think that's a separate conversation.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by davexunit on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:07PM (#15280112)
Yet users are less free now than ever before. The open source methodology leads to free libraries for devs, free labor for companies, but proprietary applications for users.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by ljcrabs on Monday September 18, 2017 @09:57PM (#15281234)
>A future where there has to be an App for that

Standardising on this means the exact opposite, there will not need to be an app for everything, just the web.

Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by fiatjaf on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:30PM (#15280267)
We? talk about yourself. I didn't have the chance to choose any of these.
Re:W3C abandons consensus, standardizes DRM, EFF resigns by bhhaskin on Monday September 18, 2017 @07:21PM (#15280551)
Do you use any Google/Apple/Facebook products? You are choosing with your wallet or personal data if you are. They only have power because we give them power either by using their products or giving them more data points.