News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Buffett wins $1M decade-old bet that the S&P500 would out... by rwmj on Sunday September 17, 2017 @03:59PM (#15271403)
Question for financial types: For a few years I've owned a small selection of shares in FTSE companies (15 of them at the moment). I don't really do this scientifically, I just look for large, well-established companies where their shares look cheaper than long run, and buy those. (Partly I do this so I can see everyday companies that I own a tiny bit of). Is this practically equivalent to owning index-linked funds? Am I missing out? I plan to hold them for many years, and it's mostly "play money".
Re:Buffett wins $1M decade-old bet that the S&P500 would out... by Lon7 on Sunday September 17, 2017 @05:02PM (#15271682)
There's two parts to this answer.

First, the numbers thrown around are that once you own 15 diversified stocks you have reduced your portfolio risk by 70 percent. That's not bad. At this point your volatility may not be that different than a market index. Of course it's different for every set of stocks, but I think this is a safe-ish guideline. So in that sense you are not missing out a whole lot.

Second, and more importantly, it is very simple to put together 15 stocks with a low volatility, but also with very low returns. This is because the vast majority of the returns of an index come from a very small number of outperforming stocks. It's like the 90-10 rule. 90 percent of an index's performance comes from 10% of the stocks. Those aren't the exact numbers, but when you only pick 15 stocks, it is very likely that you will totally miss out on all outperforming stocks.

Here's an article that talks about this in more depth and uses real numbers: http://www.efficientfrontier.com/ef/900/15st.htm

Re:Buffett wins $1M decade-old bet that the S&P500 would out... by icelancer on Sunday September 17, 2017 @07:07PM (#15272198)
>>This is because the vast majority of the returns of an index come from a very small number of outperforming stocks.

This is the only thing the parent commenter needs to read to understand why indexing is not equivalent to owning 15 stocks that theoretically reduce portfolio risk (my guess is that the stocks are highly correlated and have too high of weight towards IT and not enough towards boring fields like industrials).

Re:Buffett wins $1M decade-old bet that the S&P500 would out... by rwmj on Monday September 18, 2017 @03:41AM (#15274035)
Actually the opposite. Being in IT, I never buy IT stocks. They're mostly everyday brands and industries.
Re:Buffett wins $1M decade-old bet that the S&P500 would out... by icelancer on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:36AM (#15274694)
>>Being in IT, I never buy IT stocks.

That, ah, is even worse. Your diversification... isn't. Just because you have a job in IT doesn't mean that's adequate exposure. There is a large difference between a paycheck and investments in the large cap IT sector.

Re:Buffett wins $1M decade-old bet that the S&P500 would out... by ng12 on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @06:38PM (#15289407)
Why not? I do the opposite -- I only invest in stocks in industries I know something about. It's the only appreciable alpha I have.
Re:Buffett wins $1M decade-old bet that the S&P500 would out... by misnamed on Sunday September 17, 2017 @09:02PM (#15272660)
I wrote out a whole response (then deleted it) with that link in mind - perfect example with the other commenter's number (15). Didn't even know Bernstein's old site was still on anyone else's radar!
Re:Buffett wins $1M decade-old bet that the S&P500 would out... by anonu on Sunday September 17, 2017 @10:00PM (#15272850)
When you hold a fund (an ETF specifically) you are letting the fund manager do a lot of work for you for usually very low cost (10-20 basis points a year). That work is mainly maintaining exposure to the index. A large-cap broad-based ETF will probably hold more names than just the 15 you are holding. The benefits of that are more diversification (potentially lower vol), and regular rebalancing. So crummy names get dropped out and good ones get added in - usually with no tax consequences for you. If you manage your own portfolio of 15 names - you might argue that you could generate tax credits for yourself (tax loss harvesting) which could prove beneficial in certain situations.
Re:Buffett wins $1M decade-old bet that the S&P500 would out... by desas on Sunday September 17, 2017 @04:32PM (#15271548)
No it's precisely the opposite. You're gambling that you can beat the market for those 15 funds, index linked funds are gambling that the value of the market (index) as a whole will increase and will try to perform to the market. To do that they buy shares in all of the companies that are in the linked index (in proportion).