News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is value flowing to ICOs? It's diversification of Bit... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday September 16, 2017 @08:31PM (#15267567)
> An oft parroted rebuttal is that bitcoin is being used for speculation and very little is being used for purchases of goods and services, even though that fits the same behavior of national currencies

Are you asserting that a sizeable fraction of U.S. dollar M3 or even M2 is sitting idle speculating on the future value of the U.S. dollar?

Rates are built into modern currencies in a way they were not for gold. That's Bitcoin's fundamental problem. It's a 19th-century currency relearning old economics.

Re:Why is value flowing to ICOs? It's diversification of Bit... by ringaroundthetx on Saturday September 16, 2017 @08:40PM (#15267593)
> Are you asserting that a sizeable fraction of U.S. dollar M3 or even M2 is sitting idle speculating on the future value of the U.S. dollar?

No. But that also happens whether it is inadvertently just sitting there, or in bonds as part of a massive carry trade

Secondly did you read the article? It is about sizeable portions of bitcoin being used to invest in ICOs, which I was agreeing with and pointing out how otherwise illiquid portions of national currencies are used this way as well

Re:Why is value flowing to ICOs? It's diversification of Bit... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday September 16, 2017 @08:48PM (#15267614)
> that also happens whether it is inadvertently just sitting there, or in bonds

Bonds fund useful activity. Most ICOs have yet to finance a single developer's salary.

Re:Why is value flowing to ICOs? It's diversification of Bit... by acty1 on Saturday September 16, 2017 @09:13PM (#15267712)
District0x is paying salaries like that and many others.

The point the parent was making is that the money IS SITTING there. And bonds are not M0.... you are proving his point.

Anyone holding USD in a deposit account or loaned it out is speculating that the value of USD will remain almost the same (willing to lose 2% to inflation).

Of course someone holding a currency expects value to hold or go up. Unfortunately value of USD and other fiat goes down at exponential rate and by end of century will be practically worthless.

Imagine paper bills in year 2100. No?

Then you can imagine USA will digitize it's currency on some Blockchain of their own(this is a no brainer).

Now imagine THE Fed changing interest rates (aka Coin Emission Rate) as they please.

Pretty soon people will diversify their currency holdings away from a single country/government that can change emission (interest) rate at will and has onerous reporting and surveillance requirements.

Logical conclusion is a supra/trans-national global currency something Bitcoin or Monero.

"Granpa, was it true that when you were young you used to get paid in tree cotton papers?"

Re:Why is value flowing to ICOs? It's diversification of Bit... by danblick on Sunday September 17, 2017 @12:25AM (#15268230)
I think you are conflating "blockchain" with "electronic payment". I can use my Visa card without needing a blockchain. And banks will settle the payment electronically without ever moving paper money.

"No Timmy, I was not paid with paper money even in the 1990s."

Re:Why is value flowing to ICOs? It's diversification of Bit... by rocqua on Sunday September 17, 2017 @07:25AM (#15269136)
People like having recourse with trusted third parties. They also like universally accepted currency.
Re:Why is value flowing to ICOs? It's diversification of Bit... by ringaroundthetx on Sunday September 17, 2017 @02:57PM (#15271108)
Your quest to find a distinction is going to continue to fall apart.

Most forms of capital formation have no bearing on anything in physical goods and services economy, colloquially called "main street". ICOs are no different and I'm not sure why you feel the need to single them out.

The point here is that people are growing this currency's economy by reinvesting in new projects within that economy, just like they do in national currency economies. Thats what the article is about, thats why I've been pointing out, and what is hard to accept about that?

Re:Why is value flowing to ICOs? It's diversification of Bit... by darawk on Sunday September 17, 2017 @04:03AM (#15268696)
Most ICOs are financing developer salaries. You can quibble about whether the ICOs are funding useful work - but they're definitely paying developers.
Re:Why is value flowing to ICOs? It's diversification of Bit... by alexasmyths on Sunday September 17, 2017 @05:01AM (#15268814)
"Most ICOs are financing developer salaries."

If they are underwritten by VC's you can be assured that the terms heavily favour them, and the immediate value is going into their pockets.

It's the ultimate rub.

A free, legal way to print Monopoly money that people will trade for real money.

Re:Why is value flowing to ICOs? It's diversification of Bit... by darawk on Thursday September 21, 2017 @08:18PM (#15308392)
You could say that about nearly any investment. The trick is picking the ones that aren't Monopoly money.