I don't disagree with any of them, and frankly if you were a mod I think you'd do a fine job. Your judgment is better than mine.
If you don't care to answer publicly, you could indulge me privately. I'm a good steward of secrets. Or just tell me to buzz off. :)
Over the past couple of years I've been increasingly concerned about the severe political and cultural polarization (in general, not just on HN) and the increasing role the internet plays in people's social lives. I think it's really important that we figure out how to resolve the first and how to healthily integrate the second. HN is a great place to look at both, and one I value. It's also more tractable than others (for example, I recognize your handle as well :).
I also think that the community should play a role in maintaining itself. By far members here do want to participate in good discussion and we're only held back by our own human psychology. Often we just need to take a step back and a breath and observe what's going on. If we can help each other do that, I think we'll be in a much better position to resolving all kinds of human issues (if you'll permit a bit of naïve grandiosity). So, that's why you see the comments from me that you do.
I'm a fellow Lisp hacker, so maybe you could throw an email into your profile and we can keep in touch or swap projects.
If you're frustrated, do your best to help make the community the best it can (which is why I commented above). Make good comments, submit good articles. Member and mod reactions are indeed that—reactions to the behavior of the members on the site. If members discussed hot topics civilly and charitably, members and mods wouldn't flag and down weight. From what I've seen from the mods' comments, they'd like nothing more than to let that happen.