Re:Malicious software libraries found in PyPI posing as well...
by cookiecaper on Saturday September 16, 2017 @01:06AM
(#15262992)
EV certs have a complex verification process that can involve sending a physical representative from the company down to the place of business to confirm its presence/existence.
Bitcoin trading platforms have shown that compliance with AML/KYC regulations can be performed virtually by manual verification of a valid government ID, timestamped photo, handwritten note, and other mechanisms.
A company offering this service would go outside of the keyserver and verify the ID independently. It'd be much more of a "notarized packages" paradigm rather than just "published by 1337PyHax0r-88".
It is true that even extensive manual verification processes dependent on government-issued IDs can be faked, but there's a much higher bar involved.
Can you? Positively identifying people seems a pretty tricky and easily screwed up business.
ID's can be forged, and a web of trust requires, well, trust.
I guess such a service could say something like "we got this person's ID (and/or address)" or "here's this key's web of trust", and that would probably be a bit better than what we have today (which is virtually nothing), but it would still be a far cry from "guaranteeing it is published by someone who is who they say they are".