News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American Murder Mystery (2008) by Mz on Sunday July 18, 2010 @10:46AM (#1525838)
I don't know what the answer to problems like this is but I have spent a fair amount of time studying (both formally and informally) issues like poverty and pondering how to effectively address really thorny problems. I have concluded that government programs designed "to help the poor" generally do more harm than good. Part of the problem is with a) requiring recipients to psychologically identify themselves as "the poor" and b) the fact that the very design of such programs tends to reward people for having problems and punish them for trying to resolve their problems. A chief example is Welfare which was designed to "help poor single mothers". It was designed when most poor, single mothers were people we would classify as "the deserving poor": widows. But the way it was designed changed the social contract and actively encouraged women to choose to become poor, single moms in order to qualify for assistance. The result: Welfare actively grew the population of poor, single moms. Not remotely the original intent.

So I have concluded that if you REALLY want to "help the poor", you have to start by removing "poor" from your program definition and qualifying requirements. Instead, ask yourself: what would help the people generally and do so in such a way that, coincidentally, poor people would benefit significantly? For example, countries that help parents generally, regardless of marital status or income, seem to get better results than the American Welfare system.

Re:American Murder Mystery (2008) by alextp on Sunday July 18, 2010 @02:24PM (#1526345)
Exactly. Assistentialism is easy to defend, hard to attack ("you mean you should NOT help them?"), and spreads very easily, but totally fails to help, most of the time.

A government shouldn't build hospitals for the poor, or schools for the poor in the same sense it shouldn't have buses with separate benches for black people ("affirmative action" programs face the same problem). It a big problem of democracy as a form of government that it encourages "for show", high-visibility/low-impact, governing, and assistentialism and affirmative action fit the bill perfectly. Most rulers are not trying to help the poor, but to show that they are helping the poor.

Back where I com from, a few decades ago, there was a system of informal government called "coronelism". Affluent farmers or city politicians, called "coronéis", would build informal support networks around themselves (paying for a bright poor kid's education here, paying for a poor woman's surgery there, etc), and make it so that for most poor people they were the only way into having access to basic services of civilization. It was a crooked incentives game, and they elected themselves like this while laundering taxpayer money and sabotaging any sort of project that would provide real education, health care, etc, to the poor people, as a form of keeping control. The rest of the country needed to move forward a lot before this could be suplanted.

I feel most affirmative action programs work in the same way. You can't criticise hospitals or housing for poor people in the same way you can't criticise the "coronel" for putting that bright poor kid through college and making a lawyer/doctor/engineer out of him, but neither of these actions actually change anything in the scale of society in the long term.

Re:American Murder Mystery (2008) by Alex3917 on Sunday July 18, 2010 @12:14PM (#1526016)
"I have concluded that government programs designed 'to help the poor' generally do more harm than good."

The problem is that in most countries the poor are people who can't buy anything, whereas in the US the poor are people who can't be sold anything. They're like the spent fuel rods of capitalism. You can try to recycle them, or try to bury them, but moving them from place to place only causes trouble.

Re:American Murder Mystery (2008) by Mz on Sunday July 18, 2010 @02:03PM (#1526271)
And I would say that the problem is with viewing them primarily through the lens of their economic value to begin with, which puts them in the position you describe. That is a big part of why programs designed by the American government to help the poor typically get such dreadful results.