Re:A World Without Intellectual Property
by stretchwithme on Sunday July 18, 2010 @02:24AM
(#1525345)
Also worth pointing out is the fact that length of time one retains a right to intellectual property influences how many works are created.
Handing out rights for 70 years for literary work probably doesn't get us any more benefit than limiting them to 25 years. Writers don't really decide whether to create based on such long term considerations, so why should we give it away for nothing in return?
On the other hand, if we make the period too short, a lot fewer works would be created.
Re:A World Without Intellectual Property
by wake_up_sticky on Monday July 19, 2010 @12:53AM
(#1527661)
90% of the works created are crap anyway.
Re:A World Without Intellectual Property
by henrikschroder on Sunday July 18, 2010 @11:57AM
(#1525961)
If people will not do a kind of work we value without having their rights to the results protected, than it is necessary to do so.
Perhaps. Would people stop making music, stop writing, stop inventing if we removed IP protections?
Re:A World Without Intellectual Property
by stretchwithme on Monday July 19, 2010 @12:47AM
(#1527649)
some would and some wouldn't. I think those producing things of lasting value probably would continue. Their lives would be much more difficult though. And that doesn't seem very fair.
you must be able to keep others from taking the results of your efforts. If, for example, you could not improve a piece of property and keep the benefits for yourself, our modern society or even a primitive agricultural one would not be possible.
Our work takes many forms and so does the nature of rights associated with it. But one thing is clear. If people will not do a kind of work we value without having their rights to the results protected, than it is necessary to do so.
But we should not hand out rights if "we" aren't getting something of real value in return.
One problem is that "we" the people have far too little say about how our interests are defined and promoted by the lobbyists who have the most influence over what government does. The collective right to make such deals with innovators has been captured by private interests.