News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A World Without Intellectual Property by kiba on Sunday July 18, 2010 @01:01AM (#1525258)
I think that the existing implementation of the idea and where it has lead has numerous problems, but the fact of the matter is that it is beneficial for a society to have mechanisms like patents in place.

It has been a problem for centuries. At what point do we stop experimenting with various schema for patents and realize that is not working?

Theories that work on paper but turn out to be wrong in reality are just bad theories and should be rejected.

Re:A World Without Intellectual Property by thefool on Sunday July 18, 2010 @02:46PM (#1526417)
It's not just on paper. In my own experience I have gotten a lot of utility out of researching old patents (I do aluminum anodizing as a hobby and found detailed descriptions of stripping solutions in patents).

Society needs a system to ensure that innovations are not lost. Abolishing it is in someways similar to the idea of abolishing scientific publications. If you do that, how will breakthroughs be communicated to future generations? Or are you saying that having such a mechanism in place is a bad thing?

Just because a problem is hard and a solution hasn't been found doesn't mean that the idea motivating it is flawed.