News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm Getting Pretty Tired of Startup Advice that Doesn't I... by davidw on Tuesday April 01, 2008 @05:33PM (#152495)
I always thought that "SEO" was some basic good practices wrapped in a bunch of snake oil. At the last place I worked at a full time job, we had an "SEO expert" come in, and the boss and I concluded that 1) he was basically full of it, and that 2) the boss had a good handle on what needed doing to make various things visible. Just one anecdote, but there seem to be a lot of dubious people touting their "SEO" credentials.
Re:I'm Getting Pretty Tired of Startup Advice that Doesn't I... by antirez on Tuesday April 01, 2008 @07:11PM (#152594)
Yes basically the really important point is to avoid to develop an anti-crawler site, but this is a side effect of site with good pages semantic, structure and so on. So simply the SEO problem can be optimized away.
Re:I'm Getting Pretty Tired of Startup Advice that Doesn't I... by dejb on Tuesday April 01, 2008 @07:43PM (#152620)
Yes it is just one anecdote. Probably not enough evidence to condem the whole area of SEO. Now if you had 2 anecdotes that would be a laydown.
Re:I'm Getting Pretty Tired of Startup Advice that Doesn't I... by edw519 on Wednesday April 02, 2008 @09:52AM (#153002)
"SEO experts" are a lot like "real estate experts".

If their advice was so good, what are they doing here? They'd be way ahead if they were just out there implementing their own advice.

Re:I'm Getting Pretty Tired of Startup Advice that Doesn't I... by kingnothing on Wednesday April 02, 2008 @03:26PM (#153265)
I disagree. Some of those people may be experts at SEO but not have the first clue about how to make a good web app. The best they may be able to do is write a blog and apply SEO techniques to it to get it to the top.

On that note, If I was ever to pay someone for SEO, I'd probably Google the term and pick one of the first consulting companies that comes up.