News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by tptacek on Thursday September 14, 2017 @11:18AM (#15248879)
Organized labor has most of the same problems as organized ownership and capital. Ownership and capital has some unique problems. Labor has some other unique problems. This shouldn't surprise anyone.

Unless you're arguing for the elimination of the market system, "this structure in a market economy is prone to corruption" isn't a dispositive argument, or really an argument at all.

Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by mixmastamyk on Thursday September 14, 2017 @02:30PM (#15251006)
I often say yes, just as there are great companies and horrible companies, there are great unions and horrible unions.

If we aren't discouraging the first, why the second?

[dead]
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by tptacek on Thursday September 14, 2017 @11:40AM (#15249099)
This is approximately as rigorous an analysis as suggesting that if you hire an Italian, his mob buddies might come by later on to shake you down for protection money. How many AMA members have slashed the tires of a noncompliant doctor?
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by aeorgnoieang on Thursday September 14, 2017 @04:14PM (#15252092)
> How many AMA members have slashed the tires of a noncompliant doctor?

Why slash their tires when you can have the police arrest them, the local prosecutor press charges, etc.?

Similarly, lots of professions use police power to prevent outsiders from competing with them. Even hairstylists!

Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by arkades on Thursday September 14, 2017 @11:58AM (#15249269)
Sadly, the AMA is not a union. At best, it's an underpowered AARP analogue.
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by tedunangst on Thursday September 14, 2017 @11:52AM (#15249210)
I think the point is that the word union has a particular stigma not shared by associations not called unions.
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by tptacek on Thursday September 14, 2017 @11:58AM (#15249271)
You hear a lot of things about city bus drivers burning down houses, or telecom engineers slashing tires?

There are a lot more unions in the US than people realize. For some reason (I can think of many), high-status workers in the US are captivated by the drama of a few particular unions, and have extrapolated wildly from it.

Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by viridian on Friday September 15, 2017 @07:49AM (#15256303)
Coal unions have executed non-union shippers and started shootouts during union strikes where I'm from, back in the 30's - 70's when the town was a coal town. It's anecdotal I know, but it always colors the discussion of unions in places like Appalachia. Also the violence has gone both ways, the government at one time wasn't above plying the strong arm of the national guard against unions.
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by tedunangst on Thursday September 14, 2017 @12:05PM (#15249345)
Well, the local bus drivers union isn't held in such high regard either, so maybe not the best example. And I seem to recall Verizon experiencing a sudden spike in equipment failure right around the time their telecom union went on strike.

(Happy to concede there are unions people like, but if that's your best effort at naming two good ones, I think the problem is worse than you're acknowledging.)

Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by tptacek on Thursday September 14, 2017 @12:33PM (#15249628)
You're the one who said unions lead to tire slashings and house burnings. Obviously, no they don't, but when that's pointed out, you retreat to "unions sometimes cause strikes" as if that was your position all along.

If your argument is that people have negative opinions about unions, well, respectfully, no shit. My point is that those opinions are not well-founded.

Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by dionidium on Thursday September 14, 2017 @07:09PM (#15253232)
Minor point: the engineers at big telecoms aren't union members. They're "management."
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday September 14, 2017 @12:47PM (#15249812)
How would you rank sabotage of Verizon equipment by their employees against, say, a coal company transferring all their pension and health liabilities into new company and then letting it go bust, while they retain all the profit making parts?

"Some will rob you with a six-gun, And some with a fountain pen." -- Woody Guthrie "Pretty Boy Floyd"

Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by tedunangst on Thursday September 14, 2017 @01:05PM (#15250028)
Did the coal union know the pension was underfunded?
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday September 14, 2017 @01:07PM (#15250054)
Was it underfunded before the split?
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by concede_pluto on Thursday September 14, 2017 @03:01PM (#15251364)
Unless they somehow withdrew money from it, it can only be underfunded because it was always underfunded.
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by bnolsen on Thursday September 14, 2017 @12:32PM (#15249618)
No. The union leaders have zero interest in making any company succeed. They have a ton of interest in themselves succeeding. In fact unions work very hard against innovation and in keeping status quo.
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by tptacek on Thursday September 14, 2017 @12:39PM (#15249724)
Labor unions with professionalized management do have a short-termism problem with extracting concessions that can harm the long-term prospects of firms. That's a real problem.

Similarly, ownership and capital has a tendency to view labor as a black-box machine. If the machine, when operated in Indonesia, produces comparable financial results, what's the point in running the machine in the US? And so pretty much ever job that can be outsourced is outsourced.

Management can have the worst of both worlds. Most managers are hired guns. A ten-year stint at the helm of a company is a respectable tenure, but it's a short period of time compared to the life of some firms. Management in large firms routinely harms both employees and the long-term prospects of the firm by optimizing for short-term metric gains that boost their own compensation.

There's no part of the system that works flawlessly, or isn't freighted with obvious problems. It's kind of a miracle that things work at all. Nevertheless, they often do. And they work better for everyone when all the stakeholders are organized and engaged.

Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by scarmig on Thursday September 14, 2017 @02:17PM (#15250871)
Question: do you think German companies or American companies are better managed?

There're always issues of misaligned or perverse incentives. Although I have no illusions about union leaders having a particular interest in company success, it's not worse than company management having no particular interest in company success. And, since they have less power, they have less of a negative impact on the company and society in general.

Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by s73ver_ on Thursday September 14, 2017 @01:51PM (#15250571)
And companies have zero interest in helping any individual worker succeed, or letting them share in the company's success.
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by fsloth on Thursday September 14, 2017 @02:33PM (#15251036)
See for example how the workforce of Volkswagen is organized in germany. While I would not call it the most innovative company there is very little evidence that the political leverage employees have would have stifled innovation that much.
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by Clubber on Thursday September 14, 2017 @03:04PM (#15251405)
That's not true at all. If the company fails, all their union members are out of a job, and the union loses strength. Unions are just as interested in the company staying alive and profitable as the companies are, they just want to share more of the profits with the workers.
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by ChemicalWarfare on Thursday September 14, 2017 @03:50PM (#15251898)
Not sure why he's getting downvoted. Unions are only interested in company's existence but even then very often they are willing to see it go to the brink not budging on concessions etc. Not to mention the whole objection to the "right to work" approach.
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by sangnoir on Thursday September 14, 2017 @05:25PM (#15252646)
> Not sure why he's getting downvoted

Because his fact-free attack is demonstrably wrong. The majority of unions are invested in the companies they provide labor for. By way of example, Germany has unions that are evidently committed to the company's existence - to the extent that labor being represented at board level is not unusual. That is the kind of, ahem, synergy that should exist between capital and labor, but is anathema in the US.

In contrast, some executives are effectively mercenaries with no interest in the long-term survival of companies, they work on very short horizons, but I never hear anyone demanding that management is toxic and shouldn't exist.

Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by coredog64 on Thursday September 14, 2017 @10:48PM (#15254190)
US unions are required to have a more combative relationship with management than their German counterparts. There's a USSC decision (the name escapes me at the moment) that makes unions offer equal representation to all. So unless there is criminality, the union can't decide that you are incompetent and should find a new career. From discussions with German union members, they do have that flexibility.
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by s73ver_ on Thursday September 14, 2017 @07:14PM (#15253267)
How many times have you seen a company push their best to the brink, or just outright fire them for little to no reason? I've seen it quite a few times. So unions aren't the only ones doing what you accuse them of doing. So why call them out for it if you're not going to call the companies out for doing the same thing?
Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by mixmastamyk on Thursday September 14, 2017 @02:34PM (#15251040)
That can be true in extreme circumstances, but I'm sure you can see there is already a natural remedy to that problem.

The problem is when the company is a monopoly, which should be carefully monitored.

Re:Organizers have unionized 5,000 contract workers at Apple... by lawnchair_larry on Thursday September 14, 2017 @02:50PM (#15251218)
Do you know how Mitt Romney made his ~500M fortune?