News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Hardening of Consciousness by nabla9 on Wednesday September 13, 2017 @03:34PM (#15241792)
You are just giving definition for consciousness without any kind of good justification. It really don't answer to any questions.

For example:

1. Why loop in RL produces consciousness and other kids of loops don't?

2. In the "perception -> judgement -> action -> reward" loop, how these different parts are qualitatively different. If you remove action, does consciousness stop?

4. Following that definition even the simplest LR robot of few hundred lines would be conscious and more complex industrial robot with advanced machine vision would not be.

Re:The Hardening of Consciousness by visarga on Wednesday September 13, 2017 @11:22PM (#15244775)
> Why loop in RL produces consciousness and other kids of loops don't?

Because it helps in selecting and carrying out actions, that are necessary for maximizing rewards. In real life, reward == more life, so, by natural selection, consciousness is that function that preserves the body.

> If you remove action, does consciousness stop?

If you remove actions, there would be no purpose to be learned by the agent, so it would not form values, so it would not have emotion. It would be just a feed-forward perception system that does not develop any response to anything.

> Following that definition even the simplest LR robot of few hundred lines would be conscious and more complex industrial robot with advanced machine vision would not be.

I'd say consciousness depends on the game the agent is playing, but there is always a kind of consciousness as long as the agent can answer adaptively to changing situations and learn to act better with time.

Re:The Hardening of Consciousness by glenstein on Thursday September 14, 2017 @12:32AM (#15245028)
>In real life, reward == more life, so, by natural selection, consciousness is that function that preserves the body.

Would plants be conscious under that definition?

Re:The Hardening of Consciousness by visarga on Saturday September 16, 2017 @02:14PM (#15265816)
Yes, even bacteria should be conscious. Cells have a so called "gene regulatory network" that is analogous to a neural network where 'neurons' are genes and signals are chemical molecules. It has as many 'neurons' as genes. Every cell has such a dynamic sensing, acting and learning system allowing it to adapt to the exterior and cooperate or fight.

In complex organisms, gene regulatory networks coordinate the development of the body and internal organs. So it has the complexity necessary for consciousness, it's just a small size chemical-based consciousness, but the main ingredients are present - sensing, acting, learning and a goal - to maximize its own life and replicate, and let's not forget the most essential one - it is part of the world, which guides its evolution.

Re:The Hardening of Consciousness by glenstein on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @09:06AM (#15347366)
Late reply, but a couple of questions. (1) Would this mean that human beings in a coma or persistent vegetative state would still be considered conscious, regardless of brain activity, so long as their genes continued to regulate cell activity?

(2) does anyone in epigenetics share this view?