News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steve Yegge is a "non-notable programmer" by protomyth on Friday July 16, 2010 @04:51PM (#1522512)
Well, the featured article today is "Degrassi: The Next Generation", so I guess I know where their priorities are.
Re:Steve Yegge is a "non-notable programmer" by _delirium on Friday July 16, 2010 @05:02PM (#1522562)
I think if you were to order topics by importance for inclusion in an encyclopedia, Degrassi: The Next Generation is much higher than Steve Yegge, though there's certainly an argument for including both. Certainly it's had more cultural impact on a much larger scale than Yegge. Encyclopedia coverage isn't a judgment of quality; it's not like the criteria for covering a novel or a film is the reviews they get from literary critics or film critics.
Re:Steve Yegge is a "non-notable programmer" by protomyth on Friday July 16, 2010 @05:14PM (#1522612)
I think you hit what I believe with the phrase "cultural impact". Wikipedia doesn't deal well with a people/concepts/projects that have a technical impact on the lives of people. Look at how many video bloggers have pages then look at the technical people that influence the way we work.
Re:Steve Yegge is a "non-notable programmer" by _delirium on Friday July 16, 2010 @05:19PM (#1522635)
Some of the problem is that Wikipedia's supposed to be a tertiary source, so it can only really follow what other people choose to cover. Technical people who have had good biographies written about them, or are mentioned in history books, or anything else similar, certainly get Wikipedia articles (e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Physicists), and those who don't yet have Wikipedia articles should get them.

But if someone claims a particular technical person is important, yet they've never had a biography written about them, never even had a newspaper article written about them, never been mentioned even for a page or two in a history-of-technology book, and have basically gotten no writeups anywhere, Wikipedia shouldn't really be the first place they get a bio. The problem is really with the rest of the world: if indeed the person is important, why haven't any historians or journalists ever written about him/her? Once they do, Wikipedia can easily follow, citing those sources. As a tertiary source, Wikipedia's goal is to just summarize the existing literature, but if the existing literature itself is deficient, that's a problem that needs to be fixed elsewhere, in the primary and secondary sources. Someone in history, or in journalism, or in some similar field, needs to ask, "why aren't we writing about [x]?"

Some might just be patience. Pop culture is very time-sensitive, so is covered almost immediately-- books, journal articles, and newspaper articles appear within months or even days, which the Wikipedia article can cite. Important computer scientists do eventually get mentioned in biographies and history of technology books, but it sometimes takes years--- nobody is rushing to put out biographies right now covering "Important Computer Scientists of 2010" or anything.