In fact, your US passport has that. Look for the biometric symbol on the front. It means there's a chip inside (not sure how to read off it) that includes your digitally signed identity details, including photo.
If you're willing to go the centralized route, then a minimalist ID card would just be a QR code that anyone can open and compare the official photo to you.
"Just a qrcode" would be a weird and inconvenient format.
Other countries (Estonia, Spain, Belgium) have smartcard IDs. You can add a qrcode to that, but the primary data store can be secured (and accessed and updated) in much the same way a regular smartcard is, you can access it from your home with a regular card reader and the relevant access application. And of course the size is completely standard. And you can add contactless support to it if desirable.
Plus the US already has experience with these types of IDs: DoD has issued 17 million Common Access Cards.
Whereas digital signing can be done in an offline, airtight system, as long as the public key is widely available.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=dexlab.eCL0WN&...
But what advantage is there in having the federal government do this, instead of just having a bank issue one when you open your account? You could even use the same card with multiple creditors, which gives them access to shared credit history. Then filing for bankruptcy is the same as throwing away your bank card.
A current problem in the US is that we have three for-profit companies doing that today, whom are only really accountable to each other (sort of) and their shareholders. Their customers are each other and banks; you whose data is actually at risk are not a customer of strong value to them directly.
At one level it's a bit silly as many have passports and drivers licenses are (almost) a form of universal ID. On the other hand, I sympathize with the push against mandatory federal ID.
Digital signatures are this just as much as any other cryptography:
You can put a gun to someone's head and force them to sign something, or observe their PIN and borrow their card while they're not looking, and the signature will match. Which means it is no solution to the problem where you claim there is a valid signature and they claim it isn't legitimate and the signature can't tell you who is telling the truth.
But, your point is still true. Americans have an irrational fear of a national ID .
Americans have a rational fear of a national ID.
- drive to the government office (cost of transit)
- typically during business hours (non-free for hourly employees)
- provide some backing ID (otherwise, what's to stop somebody claiming to be me/you). That might not be free.
Basically, anything that might disenfranchise a protected class of citizen is going to have a tough time getting bipartisan support. Look no further than state-wide voter ID programs - almost all originate in conservative, GOP-led states - and almost all are thinly veiled attempts to prevent poor and minorities from voting (those two groups are more likely to support Democrats).
- Washington and Oregon votes by mail for most/all elections (>95% mail ballot). No clue how they validate the sender, but you don't have to leave the house on election day.
- NC voters have to show an ID. But, just about any official-looking bill, bank statement, pay stub, or government document with voters name and address on it will do.
- Arizona similar to NC, but if no photo ID, must show 2 non-photo documents.
The only non trivial element is how to sign the photo. I guess there must be a way to sign a degraded version of the picture so that even an average scan of the ID card would be verifiable. Or the card could contain a small, cheap, water resistant memory chip which contains the picture in digital format. Then you can have a high degree of confidence in this physical document.
And there could be other usage of that card. Like if you make it a chip & pin so the card could become an unforgeable digital signature (physical signatures are absurdly unsecure too).