Re:China to Shut Bitcoin Exchanges?
by option_greek on Monday September 11, 2017 @12:15AM
(#15215851)
Good luck banning or controlling Bitcoin - especially when there is a satellite streaming down blockchain. I understand their motive though. Large sums of money can be used for anything. Including regime change or coup.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:China to Shut Bitcoin Exchanges?
by matt_wulfeck on Monday September 11, 2017 @12:17AM
(#15215860)
I think you're underestimating China's ability to "ban" something. They don't need to make it technically impossible, they just need to make it very dangerous and burdensome. And they've basically mastered the art of internet surveillance at this point.
Re:China to Shut Bitcoin Exchanges?
by option_greek on Monday September 11, 2017 @12:23AM
(#15215885)
I think they have very few options to control or destroy btc:
1) Force chinese miners to perform 51% attack for them
2) Use their own super computers to do so
At the worst btc will fall and another might take its place. I would see these developments are exciting because the decentralization part hasn't been tested much. certainly not by a nation state actor. If BTC survives this, it will truly shine.
Re:China to Shut Bitcoin Exchanges?
by toomuchtodo on Monday September 11, 2017 @12:28AM
(#15215903)
> I think they have very few options to control or destroy btc: 1) Force chinese miners to perform 51% attack for them 2) Use their own super computers to do so
Or imprison/execute those found participating in cryptocurrencies. China does both fairly often for other crimes.
Re:China to Shut Bitcoin Exchanges?
by option_greek on Monday September 11, 2017 @12:40AM
(#15215956)
I agree. That would be the easiest to do. But in a country as big as China, underground will always flourish despite strict penalties. Even then the punishment can be heavy handed if they perceive crypto currencies as an existential threat to the regime. People forget that Chinese government is the largest and probably last such dictatorship in existence today. It is easy to forget with all the capitalism sugar coat on the top :)
Re:China to Shut Bitcoin Exchanges?
by prostoalex on Monday September 11, 2017 @12:43AM
(#15215974)
> especially when there is a satellite streaming down blockchain
If a satellite link can bypass government controls, why has it not been used by Google, FB, New York Times and numerous others banned in China?
Do you really think comparing interactive web apps, which require a bunch of complex di-directional traffic, with a blockchain, which just needs to be routinely copied from a uni-directional source, is fair?
Re:China to Shut Bitcoin Exchanges?
by prostoalex on Monday September 11, 2017 @12:57AM
(#15216036)
Fair enough on Google and Facebook, but my traffic with NYT is pretty uni-directional.
That's what you think. ;-)
Re:China to Shut Bitcoin Exchanges?
by option_greek on Monday September 11, 2017 @12:50AM
(#15215998)
Because to verify a blockchain entry, you only need to download it. To use G,FB or NYT, you need two way traffic (actively sending out a request). Verifying independently this way is important because you wouldn't know if the government has forked the chain otherwise.
Re:China to Shut Bitcoin Exchanges?
by prostoalex on Monday September 11, 2017 @12:54AM
(#15216024)
Well, the entity who needs to verify an entry is typically a miner who'd also be interested in contributing their own entries and being compensated for those contributions. What's the incentive for a miner to stay online in a read-only environment?
Re:China to Shut Bitcoin Exchanges?
by option_greek on Monday September 11, 2017 @02:45AM
(#15216487)
It is not just the miners. Say I buy BTC in gray market using local currency. How do I ensure the seller transferred BTC to my wallet. I will have to check the block chain to be sure of the transfer. Assuming great firewall is blocking all the BTC wallet clients in china through normal routes, satellite feed can still be used for verification.
Re:China to Shut Bitcoin Exchanges?
by prostoalex on Monday September 11, 2017 @03:45AM
(#15216757)
That's the buying use case. Sending BTC (either to sell or to use as a payment) still requires a broadcast to the network.
So it seems like "receiving BTC from wallets not impacted by the firewall" is the only functional use case for the satellite feed.
There's really 2 aspects to Bitcoin regulation: 1) the technology itself (hard to regulate, possibly filtered at firewall level however) and 2) the intersection of Bitcoin and fiat (ie, the exchanges). #2 is much easier to regulate, and in the end, far more effective