Re:Our entire credit bureau system is broken
by duncan_bayne on Sunday September 10, 2017 @10:51PM
(#15215557)
> This is not the direction we want to go!
Erm, what do you mean "we"? ;)
While I agree with you on all other points you mentioned, it's pretty clear to me that the voting public are _perfectly_ okay with the authority of both private and public surveillance, so long as it satisfies one or more of the following criteria:
* Reduces, or is thought to reduce, the cost of credit to the individual concerned. ("I'm okay with it, if it means I can trivially get access to credit because my credit score is good.")
* Prevents, or is thought to prevent, the risk of terrorist action or harm to children.
* Is limited to "others" (poor people, immigrants, other races, etc.).
It certainly has had help and encouragement from government mandates (SSN, drivers license/plate, monetary surveillance, etc), but even if those were eliminated it would continue just fine using its own primary keys.
As such, it can't really be top-down reformed much [0] except for correctly assigning liability for the fallout from its negligence. For instance, having to repudiate an incorrect debt from a libelous bank or surveillance company should entitle one to easily claim reimbursement for the expenses occurred (including time) to do so.
In the coming weeks we'll undoubtedly see calls to "reform" this system through the technical strengthening of the identifiers it assigns onto us. This is a recipe for rekindling belief in the authority of private surveillance as well as an invitation for it to invade even more aspects of our lives. This is not the direction we want to go!
[0] Of course we can all work on solving the problem from the bottom up by cloaking ourselves. Spend cash when possible, rotate your grocery psuedonyms often, etc.