Re:Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software de...
by famfam on Friday July 16, 2010 @12:05PM
(#1521536)
The irony of Peter Cooper advocating the Peter Principle is not lost on me.
Re:Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software de...
by gruseom on Friday July 16, 2010 @12:59PM
(#1521720)
Funny, but not as funny as if it were true. PP is when you're competent and get promoted to something you suck at; Peter's suggestion is the other way around. Sorry to nitpick.
Re:Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software de...
by btilly on Friday July 16, 2010 @01:32PM
(#1521823)
But isn't it true?
If someone is succeeding as a programmer, that says nothing about how they'll do as a manager. Therefore pushing for that promotion is a good way to wind up getting promoted to something you such at. Which is the Peter Principle at work.
Re:Ask HN: anyone ever drop everything and leave software de...
by gruseom on Friday July 16, 2010 @05:48PM
(#1522722)
Are we failing on ambiguity here? If by "it" you mean "the peter principle", then yes I think it's very true.
But here, by assumption, the programmer is not competent (I doubt this is so, but that was the context) and petercooper's suggestion -- a good one -- was to consider getting promoted into a perhaps more suitable position. That's the inverse of PP.
You seem like a prime candidate for promotion to management or a more analytical role. Is this a possibility or something you can work toward?