There are also biological/ethnic factors. Native Americans are more susceptible to alcoholism, and Asian populations are more likely to be allergic to alcohol. There are also regional differences in diet and the type of alcohol consumed, even when and how it's consumed. You can't just take a 4% number from one region and apply it generally.
And the stuff about alcoholism and allergies[1] is just you flailing to find an excuse to discredit a result you don't like. That's not the way science works. At all.
[1] FWIW: it's not an allergy at all. East asians are more likely to carry a defective gene for alcohol dehydrogenase, meaning that ethanol metabolism goes through a different process in their bodies and tends to produce an inflamation response.
Also you seem to have the impression I'm trying to disprove the study. As I stated in my original comment I'm not, I simply think they were being hyperbolic in the introduction and that annoyed me. And assuming the UK study is the sole source of that 4% number, then it's wrong and alarmist as presented and should be qualified.
I have no trouble believing their results, which are wholly unrelated to this minor point. And I hope your defensive pedantry about the definition of an allergy makes you feel better, because it doesn't disprove my argument.
I meant the UK study. You say it can't be right because brits drink more. I say that it's clearly already written as a correlation between consumption and cancer rates (because what else would it be?), which indeed makes your point sort of specious.
> defensive pedantry about the definition of an allergy
You're pontificating on the internet about the validity of alcohol studies, yet dismissing a clear fact about the same subject as "pedantry". I think that says all that needs to be said about the argument. LOL, as it were.
Amount of alcohol consumption, strength of the alcohol (I once read that only above ~15% alchohol gives you oral cancer), content of secondary alcohols like methanol, genetic factors like Alcohol flush reaction, which is known to also lead to higher cancer rates in combination with alcohol and is very common in Asia.
You lost me here. What exactly is your hypothesis about UK "drinking habits" that causes brits to get cancer at significantly higher rates than the rest of the world? All studies have to study some accessible subset of humanity. This one picked the UK.
I mean, it's OK to ask for rigor and point out problems with research, but this is an awfully big whopper of your own. You don't get to just dismiss a fairly straightforward result because warm beer.