Do you? I certainly wasn't "ready" for the workforce after graduating, but that's because I wasn't taught how to use version control software, how to manage a project, how to do proper estimates. I knew how to do Big-O estimates of algorithms, but in practice, this actually comes up rarely. (Although, admittedly, can bite you right in the ass if you don't understand what's going on.)
I don't know what sort of training bootcamps do, but if they offer practical training, it seems like there's a place for them.
Or do we want plumbers to take advanced hydrodynamics courses, rather than apprenticing?
On the other hand, if they're just teaching people to pump out code, then yeah, that's fairly useless.
Coding bootcamps are an incomplete idea. You need a program that takes you from Bootcamp to the coding equivalent of Navy Seals, and everything in between. And just as in the metaphor, for the 100 in bootcamp, maybe 1 makes it to the Seals- through years of training and real world experience.
(Meanwhile, there are a handful of Stanfords cranking out what are supposed to be the Navy seals, and not meeting demand...)
If any educational institution gave you everything you needed to know, we'd all be DaVinci's. Being too basic isn't a problem if people don't expect the learning to stop after graduation, in fact, I think this is the biggest misconception about boot camps. You're going to need to teach yourself as much as they do to be successful. Same with college.
> On some level I feel as though businesses need to get real and just pick someone for the job even entry level. There is nothing wrong with a business investing in its talent rather than expecting everyone to come in with prepackaged with everything you want them to know. Most of the people hiring these days didn't know how to do any of the stuff people are doing when they come out of bootcamp when they started their careers.
Totally agree, great dev teams, have no problem on boarding people regardless of knowledge set.
It simply isn't rational for a company to spend long periods of time on training if it expects that employee to leave not long after he is finally becoming productive.
Are you sure about this? I think it's actually the opposite: today you don't need to know anything about digital electronics, information theory, theory of computation, computer architecture, OS design, formal methods, PLT, etc. to be a very successful software developer. You just need to know how to deal with one DBMS, one high-level language, one ``framework'', and after literally a couple of years in the industry you will be making a 6 figures salary.
There have always been a large set of practical skills that aren't really taught as core CS curriculum, but most professional software engineers are going to need to be comfortable with: the version control software of the day, ways of managing runtime considerations of an application (which has obviously evolved a lot recently), certainly programming languages as well.
On some level I feel as though businesses need to get real and just pick someone for the job even entry level. There is nothing wrong with a business investing in its talent rather than expecting everyone to come in with prepackaged with everything you want them to know. Most of the people hiring these days didn't know how to do any of the stuff people are doing when they come out of bootcamp when they started their careers.