Re:Redefine statistical significance
by stdbrouw on Thursday September 07, 2017 @03:11PM
(#15194834)
This is not true at all. Small studies are simply less accurate. Would you prefer to conduct further research on a cure for cancer that's been shown to lead to recovery in 0-50% of cases (the confidence interval includes 0%, so not significant) or in .5-1% of cases (significant)?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
As a matter of fact, I can do even better than 0-50% of cases! Consuming widgets has been shown to lead to recovery in 0-100% of cases! It isn't as simple as you suggest.
Yep, and that makes widgets a more interesting target for follow-up studies than a treatment that has been shown to result in no clinically significant improvement. It really is that simple.
Surely we could create a system to fund extensions of studies with promising initial results? I just think that it is dangerous to call 95% significant.
Re:Redefine statistical significance
by Will_Parker on Thursday September 07, 2017 @07:09PM
(#15196618)
How does it make sense to suppose it could lead to recovery in 50% of cases, if a drug that does nothing has a 5% chance of producing the same result in your study?