Minecraft is a phenomenon. Why would you feel the need to talk it down as an "odd video game" just so that its price doesn't seem so high.
You apparently also think that an individual being worth the same as 1/30th of a highly successful business even though their main claim to fame was being born to the right person isn't remarkable.
> You apparently also think that an individual being worth the same as 1/30th of a highly successful business even though their main claim to fame was being born to the right person isn't remarkable.
It isn't. The Forbes list has many non-aristocrats who inherited much or all of their money and are vastly wealthier. Consider the Waltons heirs. As I said, wealth inequality is nothing new or interesting.
You also said the House of Lords is "largely inactive" which doesn't really seem connected with reality either.
Do you mind sharing why you're so keen to minimise this?
Notch shared a lot of the money, hence my focus on the total sales price. Lots of people have gotten extremely rich on an individual level from video games, if you want to nitpick about that: Gabe Newell or Palmer Luckey. There are other Asian examples, and a number of billionaires benefit heavily from video games, like Bill Gates or Mark Zuckerberg. None of this affects my point: no matter how you slice it, the quoted aristocrat is not particularly wealthy.
> You also said the House of Lords is "largely inactive" which doesn't really seem connected with reality either.
That's literally from the article.
> Do you mind sharing why you're so keen to minimise this?
Because I am incensed by lying with statistics. There is no excuse for lines like "Nearly half the land is in the hands of 432 private individuals and companies". That is lying to the reader and trying to trick them. Unforgivable.
Can you explain why you think the quote about 432 landowners is a lie and what it's trying to trick people into thinking?
Can I also note that taking a noble stand against misinformation and misleading uses of numbers seems inconsistent with the points I've already taken issue with.
> Can you explain why you think the quote about 432 landowners is a lie and what it's trying to trick people into thinking?
It is a lie because it is implying that most or all of them are aristocrats and implying 'private individuals' is a synonym for them and trying to get the reader to not notice that technically 'individuals and corporations' != aristocrats and in fact many or most of them likely are not because of the massive decimation in aristocratic wealth, while not even trying to make the case for that; it is pure begging the question, it cannot add any evidence to the claim the aristocracy still controls as large a fraction of national wealth as it ever did (at best, you could reason backwards - 'assuming they are still wealthy, then a large fraction of those 432 must be aristocrats').
A successful startup or enterpreneur achieves wealth because they create something that people want and are willing to pay for, in most cases on a non-zero sum playing field. And also if company A does X, and company B also tries to do X, there is a healthy competition in which there is usually a winning strategy for both companies. If there isn't, it is usually called a monopoly which is at least attempted to be limited by the law.
In the case of nobility, the playing field is so much unlevel that this gives them "unjust" advantages from the start. Even worse, they did not "earn" their rights by creating something new that has value, for example. And nobody calls owning the bottom of a river a monopoly, not even when they get paid by simply allowing a bridge to be built over it (does this really not sound absurd to you?).
The next question one could ask is if there is a better solution to this injustice. At this point in time, we already know several attempts at the solution, most of which failed spectacularly.
> The figures for Scotland are even more striking. Nearly half the land is in the hands of 432 private individuals and companies. More than a quarter of all Scottish estates of more than 5,000 acres are held by a list of aristocratic families. In total they hold some 2.24m acres, largely in the Lowlands.
'private individuals and companies' != 'aristocracy', by any means. You could say something very similar about the USA, which has not had an aristocracy in 200+ years - because all countries have considerable wealth inequality. And, uh, what exactly are we supposed to take away from dicing Scottish landholdings into "estates of more than 5,000 acres"? Perhaps we are supposed to be astonished by the fact that rich people buy London real estate and "rent" it out? Or perhaps we are supposed to be impressed by
> According to the 2016 Sunday Times Rich List, 30 peers are each worth £100m or more.
So in other words, they're collectively worth about as much as Magic Leap or Slack? Truly impressive, I see now that England is ruled as much as ever by the aristocracy, it is merely hidden better. Hang the bastards!