News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the British aristocracy preserved their power by pjc50 on Thursday September 07, 2017 @09:16AM (#15191502)
> carefully conflating the aristocracy of old with the modern aristocrats

> preserve the wealth they were handed over from their parents

There's a conflict between these. If your father got his wealth by driving out subsistence farmers at gunpoint, to what extent can you say it's nothing to do with you and that your wealth is a totally meritocratic inheritance?

Note that owning land is a great zero sum way to get rich. If the Duke of Westminster owns half of London, and isn't interested in selling it, you can't invest there.

> if you are so incensed at the aristocracy, why do you keep giving them power

Please explain how the people are incensed are also "giving them power" in any meaningful sense?

Re:How the British aristocracy preserved their power by sjellis on Thursday September 07, 2017 @09:37AM (#15191686)
"Note that owning land is a great zero sum way to get rich. If the Duke of Westminster owns half of London, and isn't interested in selling it, you can't invest there."

This is the point: an aristocracy is a closed shop. The article points out that land and titles can be bought, thus getting a few people and their descendents in, but it is still a system that is designed to exclude the merely capable. Schools like Eton, the London clubs and the House of Lords seats exist to create near-automatic privileges for the lucky few who were born into the "right" families.

Re:How the British aristocracy preserved their power by Boothroid on Friday September 08, 2017 @06:55AM (#15199288)
Exactly, and the nation suffers as a result of the elevation of mediocrities to positions of power.
Re:How the British aristocracy preserved their power by ZeroGravitas on Friday September 08, 2017 @07:56AM (#15199537)
There's a similar argument to be made about monopolistic corporations.

The money that Bill Gates made (and later gave some of to charity) isn't the real problem, it's the multiples of that which he destroyed via economic inefficiency or the crushing of other smaller entrepreneurs. Similarly, aristocrats who are not the absolute riches people on the planet, could still have torched Trillions in value by playing silly games to keep them on the top of the heap.

Re:How the British aristocracy preserved their power by Sacho on Thursday September 07, 2017 @09:29AM (#15191618)
> There's a conflict between these. If your father got his wealth by driving out subsistence farmers at gunpoint, to what extent can you say it's nothing to do with you and that your wealth is a totally meritocratic inheritance?

Because it wasn't your father, it was your...how many generations are there between us and the middle ages, again? This is a time jump in the article itself:

> Historically, the British aristocracy’s defining feature was not a noble aspiration to serve the common weal but a desperate desire for self-advancement. They stole land under the pretence of piety in the early middle ages, they seized it by conquest, they expropriated it from the monasteries and they enclosed it for their private use under the pretence of efficiency.

> .....

> And when democracy finally and rudely shunted them aside, they found new means of preserving their extravagant riches without the tedium of pretending they sought the common interest. Far from dying away, they remain very much alive.

Moreover, the UK has been a democracy for quite some time now, and has had ample time to address inheritance law, and land ownership law. Like the article states:

> That is no accident. British laws on land tenure, inheritance tax, corporate governance and discretionary trusts still make it easy to hide wealth from public view. Land is subsidised, and taxed more lightly than residential property. Unearned income bears less of a burden than earned income.

The article claims that this is the secret to the power of the aristocracy. This power is given to them by laws, designed and voted in by MPs, who are in turn voted in by the people.

Re:How the British aristocracy preserved their power by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday September 07, 2017 @09:46AM (#15191781)
It's easy to pretend to be a democracy when you own all the top schools, the popular press, the top universities, the civil service, the land, and all the core businesses.

Democracy does not mean the peasants get to vote. Democracy means that the peasants get to set policy for their own benefit - which means that improving the opportunities, prospects, and living conditions of the majority of the population becomes a national goal, not an occasional failure of default policy.

In a genuine democracy this happens with honest and open public debate and effective economic and political action, not with rhetoric, dishonesty, demagoguery, and misdirection.

Re:How the British aristocracy preserved their power by crdoconnor on Thursday September 07, 2017 @10:39AM (#15192242)
>Because it wasn't your father, it was your...how many generations are there between us and the middle ages, again? This is a time jump in the article itself:

Does it really matter if the Duke of Westminster got his land because his father fought a war or because his great^10 father fought a war? The 'moral argument' for society granting him billionaire status is still based entirely upon a past war and primogeniture.

>Moreover, the UK has been a democracy for quite some time now

Democracy isn't binary, it's a continuum. The media is largely owned by elites and until recently, the internal party political machinery of the two major parties were too.

The Duke of Westminster's wealth wasn't stripped because British citizens really wanted him to keep it. He got to keep it because it wasn't seen as a fight worth starting to take it back.

Re:How the British aristocracy preserved their power by pjc50 on Thursday September 07, 2017 @09:36AM (#15191685)
> the UK has been a democracy for quite some time now, and has had ample time to address inheritance law, and land ownership law

This is true, and it hasn't had time to do it since first properly overruling the Lords in 1911. For some reason the newspapers owned by Lord Rothermere have agitated against it.

The Scottish government has had much less time (since May 1999) to work on the subject and has got much further with land reform.

Re:How the British aristocracy preserved their power by ZeroGravitas on Thursday September 07, 2017 @05:17PM (#15195811)
And the tiny steps it has taken (e.g. suggesting it would be good to know who owns all the land) were denounced as being akin to Mugabe's actions in Zimbabwe by prime minister David Cameron's father-in-law who just happened to be a major land owner.
Re:How the British aristocracy preserved their power by dghf on Thursday September 07, 2017 @09:53AM (#15191835)
> Because it wasn't your father, it was your...how many generations are there between us and the middle ages, again?

Enclosure of common land took place mostly in the 18th century. The Highland Clearances went on into the 19th.