Makes it more likely that Matt/WP would prevail on what?
That Thesis infringes on WP copyright by using some GPL code, or that add-ons like themes are truly derivative works?
The article seems to confirm the former, but not the latter.
That Thesis infringes on WP copyright by using some GPL code, or that add-ons like themes are truly derivative works?
The article seems to confirm the former, but not the latter.
Take the code, filter out the abstract concepts, the purely functional expression, and finally the short words and phrases in what was left. Some other courts would impose a further filter based on fair use and interoperability.
Take a look at the diff and apply some of those filters in your mind. After all those filters, I am unsure what, if anything, would be left.
EDIT: I had thought that this might be a case of parallel development, but Rick Beckman (former dev for Thesis) just posted that there was copy-paste from WordPress core - he did it. (http://ma.tt/2010/07/syn-thesis-1/#comments, Rick Beckman @8:41) Although that doesn't make it completely open-and-shut, it makes it significantly more likely that Matt/WP would prevail.