News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An analysis of GPLed code in Thesis by VanL on Thursday July 15, 2010 @04:52PM (#1519142)
This is a better analysis than most, but it is unlikely that a court analyzing this would stop there. The court would probably use the Abstraction/Filtration/Comparison test.

Take the code, filter out the abstract concepts, the purely functional expression, and finally the short words and phrases in what was left. Some other courts would impose a further filter based on fair use and interoperability.

Take a look at the diff and apply some of those filters in your mind. After all those filters, I am unsure what, if anything, would be left.

EDIT: I had thought that this might be a case of parallel development, but Rick Beckman (former dev for Thesis) just posted that there was copy-paste from WordPress core - he did it. (http://ma.tt/2010/07/syn-thesis-1/#comments, Rick Beckman @8:41) Although that doesn't make it completely open-and-shut, it makes it significantly more likely that Matt/WP would prevail.

Re:An analysis of GPLed code in Thesis by slantyyz on Thursday July 15, 2010 @05:49PM (#1519342)
Makes it more likely that Matt/WP would prevail on what?

That Thesis infringes on WP copyright by using some GPL code, or that add-ons like themes are truly derivative works?

The article seems to confirm the former, but not the latter.