Re:GPL and the Wordpress x Thesis theme issue (Why Chris is ...
by wazoox on Thursday July 15, 2010 @04:00PM
(#1518956)
The comparison with Linux modules is problematic. Many people consider Linux proprietary modules illegal.
See for instance: http://www.oreillynet.com/linux/blog/2006/08/why_binaryonly_...
Re:GPL and the Wordpress x Thesis theme issue (Why Chris is ...
by travem on Thursday July 15, 2010 @03:51PM
(#1518938)
If that API is under the GPL then isn't use of it a derivative work? If the API is a GPL implementation of a standard API, e.g. the JDBC API, then it wouldn't be a derivative work, not sure if Themes call a wordpress specific API or not though.
Re:GPL and the Wordpress x Thesis theme issue (Why Chris is ...
by dedward on Thursday July 15, 2010 @04:01PM
(#1518960)
I think that's a great question, and one that could probably spawn a ton of interesting legal/logical arguments.
At what point does dynamic linking make something a derived work - and how is dynamic linking fundamentally different, than, say, a remote procedure call (or SOAP or REST or whatever) over a network? The interface is different, but the principle is the same.
Also - the GPL does state that it's okay to link against things that are "standard parts" of the target system....
Re:GPL and the Wordpress x Thesis theme issue (Why Chris is ...
by jasonlotito on Thursday July 15, 2010 @04:24PM
(#1519032)
Realize you posted this before the above post was made, but apparently thesis is using Wordpress code, and not just the API.
http://drewblas.com/2010/07/15/an-analysis-of-gpled-code-in-...
Re:GPL and the Wordpress x Thesis theme issue (Why Chris is ...
by mattdawson on Thursday July 15, 2010 @04:27PM
(#1519045)
Ahh. Well, nevermind my other comment in this thread. If he's ripping off WP core code, then yes, Thesis should definitely be GPL'd.
Thesis integrates with Wordpress, it is not derivative from it. Same way Linux modules integrate with the Linux kernel (and many of them are closed source).
If someone is using a public/open API, and not distributing any part of the software, it means they are not based on the other.