News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An analysis of GPLed code in Thesis by tzs on Thursday July 15, 2010 @02:20PM (#1518624)
I'm impressed. The author starts with this disclaimer:

> I’m not a lawyer, I’m a developer. My views here are my own and are based on TECHNICAL knowledge and experience with the GPL, not on the law (which astute observers will note often does not reflect real life)

I was not expecting much, therefore, in the way of accurate legal analysis, yet a couple paragraphs later he goes on to show the errors in the SFLCs analysis, and then goes on to correctly state what is required for something to be a derivative work, and then analyzes the theme in question to see if it is a derivative work.

If he had left off the disclaimer, and tossed in a couple of direct case citations in proper legal citation format (instead of just citing another blog that cited a major case), I'd have not guessed that he wasn't a copyright lawyer.

There are no comments on this comment yet.