Well, okay. What I meant was that your criticism implied that he didn’t understand/address implicit tags, while he clearly actually did, but just suggested they be dropped.
I also hope his examples were more like a sketch than a careful proposal – otherwise, as you said, there’s a lot of ambiguity.
Anyway, there are clear advantages and disadvantages to both models. I’m not personally convinced that either HTML or S-expressions is an especially good document format, at least not as far as a human trying to create a document is concerned, but fortunately these kinds of languages are easy enough to generate that the original source language can pretty much look like whatever someone can imagine.
Not exactly... he basically said "let's drop the current spec and use lisp".
The thing I noticed when looking at language design though is that it's really easy to say "language X should look like Y" but overlook something that makes the whole proposal a really bad idea. Case in point: can you spot the problems on his lisp example? (hint: elements vs text nodes, required escape sequences)