Re:Stop Faking Service Dogs
by tptacek on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @10:55PM
(#15180864)
It has to be a dog, you have to pass it off as a service animal, and you have to do so in a way that meets the CA legal standard for "fraudulent". It's a little silly that there's a specific statute for it (and that it only covers dogs), but it's really just a refinement of the crime of fraud, which most assuredly is a crime in Europe too.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Stop Faking Service Dogs
by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @11:56PM
(#15181094)
But that's sort of the point -- if it's redundant with fraud then why does it need a separate law?
In US common law, fraud requires that the victim bear some sort of loss (injury), and there's none in this particular set of circumstances. So existing fraud law isn't generally sufficient to cover this particular set of circumstances.
Re:Stop Faking Service Dogs
by shawn-butler on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @02:43AM
(#15181682)
Because legislators don't feel they have accomplished something if they don't get their name on a statute.
A little free publicity on a controversial one doesn't hurt either.
One of the things that this visitor to CA found disturbing was how so many signs have the code number of the law listed on it. Made the visit feel more police-state-ey. Even the little cart that carries tourists up the hill at Alcatraz had a "do not board moving vehicle" sign on it with a legal reference.
CA has a really weird relationship with government.
Re:Stop Faking Service Dogs
by kinkrtyavimoodh on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @02:01AM
(#15181548)
I think it's cool that you can go look up the code number and know exactly what the law is and what it requires you to do. Surely that is less police state than a board just screaming penalties?