Re:Time for Makefiles to Make a Comeback
by llimllib on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @12:17PM
(#15176617)
(disclaimer: I like make but not macros)
> And make has deficiencies that are a nightmare to work around and get right (e.g. spaces in filenames, recursion, ...)
Yes! we seem to be stuck in a local maximum with make. I wrote my own make replacement, as have many before me, and learned the folly of my own ways.
Nowadays I use (and love) make despite its terrible handicaps, but I really wish there were something fundamentally similar but a) less C-focused and b) containing many fewer footguns.
Re:Time for Makefiles to Make a Comeback
by lederhosen on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @06:03PM
(#15179486)
Shake is similar to Make with some improvements (it is a Haskell DSL), I have not used it, but it looks good.
I wrote a book on make and I fully recognize that there are people who look at what I've written there and think I'm completely mad: https://www.nostarch.com/gnumake
Make's greatest irony is that it's a system for building files based on dependencies but has no way of actually discovering dependencies. I wrote about this for Dr Dobbs a while back: http://www.drdobbs.com/architecture-and-design/dependency-ma...
And make has deficiencies that are a nightmare to work around and get right (e.g. spaces in filenames, recursion, ...)
If anyone else out there is a make hacker like myself they might enjoy the GNU Make Standard Library project: http://gmsl.sourceforge.net/