News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube-mp3 agrees to shut down by pavel_lishin on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @10:46AM (#15175695)
> I don't think you need a server or any such thing, and the only way to force a take down would be to take down the underlying services.

What's to stop the MPAA/RIAA and ISPs from just suing everyone on the network who's hosting part of the file? If they can sue bittorrent users, what's the significant legal difference here?

Re:YouTube-mp3 agrees to shut down by saalweachter on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @10:54AM (#15175794)
There's probably nothing to stop them, but it's way more hilarious. Anonymous internet people start using the networks for various flavors of illegal file storage, and various innocent network operators just trying to sell shovels in a gold rush or run a simple pyramid scam start getting sued by the RIAA or prosecuted by the FBI, while the original uploaders (or even the smart contracts to maintain and index the uploads) are dust in the wind.
Re:YouTube-mp3 agrees to shut down by pavel_lishin on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @11:30AM (#15176193)
I don't think I'd call random innocent people getting served with lawsuits "hilarious".
Re:YouTube-mp3 agrees to shut down by saalweachter on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @01:43PM (#15177436)
It's hilarious because people have been jumping into running services without necessarily considering the legal liabilities they've been signing up for.

It's like if someone started a point-to-point delivery business where they take anonymous, secure packages between different places, no questions asked, and then are surprised when the police show up and say they're pretty sure that a good portion of the packages they've been carrying are drugs and pipe bombs, and ask them to roll on their clients, or at least stop delivering packages. And then the delivery man tries to make a philosophical argument that they aren't morally or legally responsible for the contents of their packages, and in any case it really shouldn't be illegal to distribute drugs or pipe bombs.