Once you approach the limits of an RDBMS you're in really large application territory and very few of us will be working for a Facebook or Google.
I'm just saying I like separation of concerns.
I've worked on some large apps and almost always had separation of concerns - the database is ultimately responsible for data integrity. It will validate foreign keys, data ranges and types, but does not implement write business logic. This takes advantage of the amazing work put in to query planners but avoids most of the magic that triggers cause.
I'm complaining about things like PL/SQL letting you send an email inside a trigger (http://www.orafaq.com/wiki/Send_mail_from_PL/SQL), or Postgres's XML processing features. I don't think that belongs in the DB.
It's easy to say "don't do that" to a small team, but when you get to the corporate shops that do Oracle, that becomes a much harder thing to enforce.
We have an application to track and distribute work to employees, there can only be one active work item per item type on an account - we use MSSQL for this and originally enforced this with a CHECK constraint, which ultimately failed, we switched to a partial index (CREATE UNIQUE INDEX ON activities(account_id, activity_type) WHERE activity_state = 0) which works flawlessly. There is absolutely no sane way to implement this at the application layer, and even then we have additional applications and administrative work that may access this database directly so we can't rely on the application enforcing data integrity anyway. MySQL doesn't even support CHECK constraints, nor does it have partial indexes - while even SQL Server has supported partial (filtered) indexes since SQL Server 2008 (nearly a decade after PostgreSQL implemented them, but hey, still at least a decade before any of the MySQL family will have them).
Should you put application logic in your database? No, probably not. But you should always make sure your database prevents ANY invalid data from being put into it, your little application won't be the only one touching that database forever in all likelihood.
Ha...that's a bit of a hack! I've had to do a similar trick for a unique constraint on columns where we didn't care if the value was null. SQL Server (for some reason) considers null a value in this case; in other words, there could only be one null value in the table for purposes of a unique constraint.
E.g:
create unique index on (col) where col is not nulla) a needlessly uncivil thing to write
b) just the fact that you're (rudely) giving me the religion on CHECK constraints means you've probably never actually scaled a DB for high transaction volume. Once you have to start sharding and denormalizing for performance, we've left ACID territory, and most of the validation has to be in the application anyway.
I just don't think sending emails and parsing XML should run in the database.
The ability to stop modifications inside the db is the ultimate safeguard against data corruption. If you really value your data you should also implement validations with CHECK statements and not only in the application. Think about the database as another microservice worth its own logic.
I'm talking about not doing shit like XML parsing (https://www.postgresql.org/docs/9.6/static/functions-xml.htm...), or LDAP queries (https://docs.oracle.com/cd/B10501_01/network.920/a96577/dbms...) in the database. I don't think those things belong there.
Serves me right for leaving a blank on HN! People here just love to fill those with 'herp derp'.
Front end (JS SPA) for the convenience of users.
Back end API (any web framework) for the convenience of developers, the users of the API.
The database to make sure nobody can corrupt the data.
In my experience the validations in the database almost never go past foreign keys, null fields and bounds on numeric data.
Anecdote. I remember when the consensus of Rails developers was not to use foreign keys: Rails didn't have a way to define them so they probably didn't matter, right? I laughed and added them to every application of mine. Rails has foreign keys now, maybe since version 3.
There are some gems to generate CHECK statements from validations.
With richer RDBMSes like Oracle, MSSQL, and Postgres, people tend to throw too many responsibilities on the DB--which is not so good in the one part of the system that depends on global locks.
That, and the article is kind of a half-truth when it comes to the MySQL warts. A big one he missed is the utf8_unicode vs utf8mb4_unicode fiasco, which is still a thing to the best of my knowledge...