After all, they brought the merb devs into Rails core and radically re-architected the whole framework to support modularity and customization down to a very low level. From the extraction of ActiveModel, to the inclusion of Thor for generators, the decoupling of Prototype and an ambitious attempt at unobtrustive javascript, and the declaration of a publicly support API upon which even the framework itself is built, Rails 3 the biggest overhaul Rails has ever had.
Have they succeeded in making it truly modular? I dunno, it's not released yet for one thing, but to say it's a crap shoot is a bit premature IMO.
I first used rails very early on, late 2003 no... maybe it was early 2004. Anyway I didn't like it then but it did save my ass in getting my college project done.